Cheapest Car Insurance in New York

Fact-checked with HomeInsurance.com

1

At Bankrate we strive to help you make smarter financial decisions. While we adhere to strict , this post may contain references to products from our partners. Here’s an explanation for

In New York state, the average cost of car insurance is $974 a year for minimum coverage, and $2,205 yearly for full coverage in New York. This puts New York in 3rd place for most expensive states, behind Michigan in 2nd, and Florida, which tops the list.

Like most states, car insurance is legally required in New York, whether you live in the Big Apple or the Adirondacks. However, you can still find cheap car insurance in New York if you’re on a budget by comparing average rates from top providers.

The cheapest car insurance companies in New York

As of 2018, nearly 12,194,360 licensed drivers fill the streets in New York. To meet demand, dozens of car insurance providers operate in New York — some more expensive than others.

Bankrate researched to find and compare the cheapest car insurance companies in New York, including average rates for each provider, based on data from Quadrant information services.

The table below indicates the cheapest car insurance companies in New York, and is followed by descriptions of each car insurance company for your comparison.

Cheapest car insurance companies in New York

Insurance company Average minimum coverage Average full coverage
Main Street America $266 $741
Utica National Insurance Group $620 $4,506
Progressive $638 $1,102
Erie $679 $1,575
Geico $690 $1,853

Quadrant information services, 2020

Main Street America

Main Street America has one of the cheapest average minimum coverage car insurance rates for drivers in New York. With comprehensive coverage and collision coverage, medical expense coverage, and bodily injury and property damage liability coverage, Main Street America offers a well-rounded selection of protection for you and your vehicle.

Main Street America also offers some of the most affordable prices for full coverage, which can be personalized to fit your needs, budget and coverage goals. The insurance company offers additional coverage options that include new vehicle replacement, accident forgiveness, roadside assistance, loan-lease protection and full safety glass. In addition to extensive coverage features and low rates, Main Street America is a popular choice for New Yorkers because of the various discounts that can be applied to further save on costs.

Utica National Insurance Group

New Yorkers may find Utica National Insurance Group an attractive insurance company because of comparable premiums, great customer service and extensive list of add-on coverages. Utica offers a unique customer service experience through its customer care portal, which can be beneficial for drivers who prefer step-by-step customer support.

Own a pet? Some of Utica National Insurance Group’s auto policies will also cover up to $750 of vet costs for injuries related to auto accidents. Another great benefit of Utica National Insurance Group is the flexibility and adaptability of insurance premiums based on drivers’ life changes. Whether you were recently married, divorced, need to add a child, are moving out of your home or going to college, Utica National Insurance Group offers solutions to fit your changing auto insurance needs.

Progressive

When you think about Progressive, you probably think about Flo, the brand’s iconic spokeswoman who stars in their advertisements. But you might not know that Progressive’s car insurance rates are surprisingly affordable. In fact, drivers save an average of over $750 when they switch to Progressive. The average New Yorker will spend $1,102 per year on a full coverage car insurance policy from Progressive.

In terms of discounts, Progressive is ahead of the game. The company’s signature Snapshot program rewards safe drivers with a lower premium (about $145 savings, on average). Drivers can also use the Name Your Price Tool to see the best coverages within their budget. In addition to some basic discounts, Progressive also has a deductible savings bank, where drivers can lower their premium by $50 for each policy period without a claim or traffic violation.

Erie

Although on the higher end of the other insurance companies listed above by price, Erie offers extra coverage that many New York drivers will find attractive. From pet coverage, roadside and rental bundles, locksmith services, auto glass repairs and personal item coverage, Erie goes beyond basic coverage. In addition, Erie offers a 20% multi-policy discount, for drivers who own boats, motorcycles or other automobiles and insure them all with Erie.

As insurance premiums can change upon renewal, Erie offers a rate lock service to guarantee that your rate will remain the same, once locked in at the start of your policy. With this feature, your rates will only change after you make certain changes to your car insurance policy such as adding or removing a driver or vehicle and changing your location; claims will not necessarily cause your rate to increase.

Geico

Geico is one of the most popular insurance companies in New York and across the country. It makes sense why it offers some of the cheapest rates you can find. U.S. News and World Report estimates that the average price of a Geico policy in New York is $1,201.80 per year. In addition to low prices, Geico offers a ton of great discounts for all types of drivers. For instance, safe drivers, good students, military personnel and federal employees qualify for savings. You can also save money by having certain vehicle safety equipment in your car, like anti-lock brakes, airbags and daytime running lights.

Affordable coverage for New York drivers

Every state requires drivers to carry a minimum amount of car insurance—New York is no different. New York is also considered a no-fault state, which means New York drivers have to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP).

Here are the minimum car insurance requirements in New York:

  • Property damage liability: $10,000 for a single accident
  • Bodily injury liability: $25,000 for bodily injury for one person and $50,000 for bodily injury to all persons.
  • Mandatory no-fault coverage: $50,000
  • Bodily injury liability: $50,000 for bodily injury and $100,000 for death for two or more people in an accident
  • Uninsured motorist coverage: $25,000 per person and $50,000 for all persons.

Purchasing the minimum amount of insurance means you’ll pay the lowest rate. However, you shouldn’t assume that New York’s minimum car insurance requirements are enough to cover the full cost of a claim. If you get involved in an accident, it’s possible that the cost of the claim will exceed your coverage limits. In that case, you would have to pay out-of-pocket to cover the difference.

Because of that, choosing the minimum amount of car insurance is not the best way to keep your rate low. In fact, it could cost you more money in the long run if you have to file a claim that your insurance doesn’t fully cover.

How to get cheap car insurance in New York

If you’re looking to keep your car insurance rate low, you have a few options:

  • Take advantage of discounts: Make sure you’re taking advantage of all the discounts you are eligible for. Most insurance companies offer savings for drivers who take a defensive driving course, pay their premium in full and sign up for paperless billing statements.
  • Improve your credit score: Your credit score is one of the main factors that influences your rate. If you can increase your credit score, even by a few points, there’s a good chance you can lower your premium.
  • Increase your deductible: Your deductible is the amount of money you’re required to pay out-of-pocket towards a loss. The higher your deductible, the lower your monthly payments will be. Just make sure you can afford a higher deductible before you change it.
  • Shop around: Arguably, the best way to get cheap car insurance is to make sure you’re paying the lowest rate to begin with. Shop around and get quotes from a few providers to see what they’ll offer you.

These simple steps can help reduce your premiums.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best car insurance in New York?

The best car insurance company in New York is different for every driver. You should choose a car insurance company that offers what you’re looking for, whether it’s cheap rates, great customer service, customizable coverage, or something else. Before you settle on a provider, it’s important to do some research to find a company that checks all the boxes for you personally.

How much does car insurance in New York cost?

The average cost of car insurance in New York state is $1,349.72 per year. However, the actual rate you’ll pay depends on factors like your age, credit score, zip code, the car you drive, the car’s value, and more.

Is car insurance required in New York?

Yes, car insurance is legally required in New York. If you’re caught driving without insurance, there can be serious consequences. New York drivers must carry a minimum amount of bodily injury liability, uninsured motorist, and property damage coverage. Because New York is a no-fault state, drivers also have to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) insurance.