How to choose the right, cheap car insurance for your budget
The Bankrate promise
At Bankrate, we strive to help you make smarter financial decisions. To help readers understand how insurance affects their finances, we have licensed insurance professionals on staff who have spent a combined 47 years in the auto, home and life insurance industries. While we adhere to strict , this post may contain references to products from our partners. Here's an explanation of . Our content is backed by Coverage.com, LLC, a licensed entity (NPN: 19966249). For more information, please see our .
Many Americans are on a budget, and with inflation continuing to rise, those budgets are getting tighter than ever. One constant in many peoples’ budget is car insurance, as almost all states require a minimum amount of coverage. To give you an idea of the average rate Americans pay, the average annual cost of car insurance is $1,771 for full coverage and $545 for minimum coverage. So, how can you choose the right, cheap car insurance for your budget? Bankrate’s insurance experts help you understand the factors that go into your car insurance rates and what you can do to get the best rate to fit your budget.
How to choose the right, cheap car insurance
If you are looking for the cheapest car insurance, focusing on price is essential. However, you should also consider factors besides price to find the right car insurance company. There are a few things worth considering to help narrow down your options, such as your location, your driver profile and the discounts that might be available to you.
1. Consider your vehicle and driving record
Your car insurance premium is based on many factors, including the make and model of your vehicle, the age of your vehicle, the mileage and its safety features. Because older vehicles usually have a lower value, they are often cheaper to insure than newer cars with more expensive parts and repair costs. Plus, you may be able to forego full coverage, saving even more by removing coverage options you no longer need. Talk to your insurance agent to see what coverage options are right for you and your car.
In addition, your driving record, including the number of at-fault accidents and moving violations you have received, could have a significant impact on your car insurance rate. Generally speaking, safe drivers pay the lowest car insurance rates. If you have serious violations on your driving record that require you to get SR-22 insurance, you might be required to purchase high-risk auto insurance, which usually has a much higher premium.
2. Consider your personal factors
Besides your driving record, other personal factors will impact your car insurance quote. Some personal factors include your age, credit score, state, ZIP code and the number of miles you drive annually. However, California, Hawaii, Massachusetts and Michigan ban or restrict the use of credit as a factor in your car insurance rates, while Hawaii and Massachusetts do not permit age as a rating factor. California and Michigan also restrict the use of ZIP codes to determine rates.
Because car insurance quotes can vary significantly based on driver profile, getting multiple quotes is valuable. Each insurance company calculates rates differently and weighs each factor according to a unique formula. What that means is that if you have certain issues that may cause you to pay more for insurance, like a minor fender bender on your driving record, you may find that one provider offers much cheaper rates than another.
3. Compare quotes based on coverage
When shopping for an insurance company, comparing quotes is one of the most helpful things you can do. In addition to your driver profile, your chosen coverage limits, add-ons and deductibles will also determine your rate. Make sure to get several quotes for the same type and amount of coverage for accuracy.
The amount of car insurance coverage you need has a direct impact on your premium. As a general rule, the higher your coverage limits are, the more your policy will cost, but the greater financial protection you have if you need to file a claim. On the other hand, choosing a high deductible could help you secure a lower rate. However, you should consider whether you can afford to pay a higher deductible if you were to get into an accident.
If you lease or finance your car, you will probably need to purchase a full coverage policy, which includes collision, comprehensive and liability. If you own your vehicle, you may have the option to purchase a cheaper minimum coverage policy that includes minimum coverage only, but it will not offer as much financial protection.
4. Understand which discounts may apply to you
As you compare insurance providers, pay close attention to the discounts offered. Many car insurance companies offer discounts to help drivers get a better rate, but the discounts available are unique to each carrier. Here are some commonly available car insurance discounts:
- Multi-policy: Purchasing two or more policies from the same company, usually as a home and auto insurance bundle, could help you get a cheaper premium.
- Multi-vehicle: If you insure more than one vehicle on your auto insurance policy, many insurance providers will lower your rate.
- Claim-free: Drivers who have no insurance claims on their record within the last several years can sometimes qualify for a claim-free discount.
- Pay in full: If you can afford to pay your annual premium upfront and in full, you can probably save some money on your premium.
- Good student: Drivers who get good grades in high school or college can often qualify for a student car insurance discount.
- Telematics: Many carriers offer telematics programs, which monitor driving habits for both safe and risky behaviors behind the wheel. Safe drivers can often save on their premiums, but some companies may raise your rates if the program uncovers risky habits that can increase the chance of an accident.
If you qualify for multiple discounts, most insurance companies allow them to be stacked together, which lets you maximize savings if you qualify for more than one. You can ask about the discounts that are available so you know what you may qualify for when choosing a company. Applying discounts may help lower the cost of car insurance so you can get the policy you need without compromising your coverage.
5. Research trusted third-party ratings
In addition to car insurance quotes and coverage options, it is also a good idea to look at third-party ratings for every provider you are considering. Some of the most notable and trustworthy organizations are J.D. Power, AM Best and Standard & Poor’s (S&P). By considering third-party ratings, you are able to get a deeper understanding of the company’s overall customer satisfaction and financial stability, which show a company’s past ability to pay claims and meet financial obligations.
Frequently asked questions
Since each driver’s rates are calculated individually, there is no cheapest car insurance company for everyone. To find the cheapest car insurance company for you, it may be helpful to get several quotes from different companies to compare the options. This may allow you to see how each company’s rates differ from the others while ensuring that the coverage is comparable. From there, you can determine what the cheapest car insurance company is for your unique situation.
Yes, you may be able to switch car insurance companies and get a better rate. However, it will depend on a number of factors, including whether your current insurance company is charging higher than average rates for your coverage. Drivers generally have the option to switch car insurance carriers at any time, though it may be easier to do so at renewal. Before you make any changes, though, it may be helpful to compare quotes from several carriers and weigh the quotes and potential discounts against what you are paying for your current policy to see which option is best.
There are several ways you can purchase car insurance, including in person, online or over the phone. When you are ready to purchase car insurance, there are a few steps you may need to take to complete the process. For starters, you may need to gather paperwork, determine your coverage needs and shop for car insurance quotes. From there, you will need to determine which option is best for you and then fill out the application. You will also need to pay for at least the first month’s premium to have an active policy on your vehicle.
Even though it may make sense that a cheaper car will have cheaper car insurance, that is not always the case. Many factors go into car insurance rates, including the make and model of your vehicle, its safety ratings and other features. The cost of parts and repairs also factor into the price for each car, so a cheaper car with expensive repair costs and few safety features may be more expensive to insure than a newer, safer car. If you are considering a cheaper car, gather a few makes and models you are considering and get a quote for each to compare the potential cost of auto insurance to help you make a decision.
How long you should keep full coverage on a car depends on a few factors. If you can afford to replace the car if it is totaled, then you may no longer need full coverage. You can also calculate the value of your car to see if the cost of full coverage is worth it. Keep in mind, however, that if you finance or lease your vehicle, the lender may require you to maintain full coverage until the loan is satisfied. If you’re not sure if full coverage car insurance is right for you, speak with your insurance agent.