When an unexpected expense comes your way or you’ve been wanting to make a larger purchase, choosing between a personal loan and a credit card can be difficult. There are distinctions between the two, and knowing when to take out a personal loan or use your credit card can prevent financial challenges down the road.
If you need to take out a large lump sum of money for a project or want to pay off high-interest credit card debt, then you may want to consider a personal loan. If you’re making a smaller, everyday purchase, a credit card is the better option.
Differences between a personal loan and a credit card
A personal loan provides a lump-sum payment on which you make fixed monthly payments until your balance is paid. Loans are typically used for a larger expense or debt consolidation.
A credit card is a revolving line of credit, meaning that you can repeatedly borrow funds up to a predetermined borrowing threshold also known as a credit limit. Because of this, a credit card is typically best for ongoing daily purchases.
Here are some key differences you should be aware of when deciding which route to go:
||Pay the minimum amount or the full accrued balance by the monthly due date||Make fixed monthly payments during a set period, typically between 12 and 60 months|
|Interest||Variable interest that accrues on unpaid balances||Fixed interest for the entirety of the loan|
||Revolving line of credit: You’ll have access up to your monthly credit limit||Lump sum: You’ll receive the full loan amount at once|
|Fees||Annual fees, late fees, over-limit fees, foreign transaction fees, etc.||Origination fees, prepayment fees, late fees, etc.|
While there are many differences between a personal loan and a credit card to consider, there are also some important similarities.
“Both a credit card and a personal loan allow a consumer to conserve cash, purchase now and pay later,” says Jeff Arevalo, financial wellness expert for GreenPath Financial Wellness. “Both require on-time payments and responsible use so as not to negatively affect your credit or ability to secure funding in the future.”
When to use a personal loan
Taking out a personal loan makes the most sense when you know you’re able to make the monthly payments for the full length of the loan.
Here are a few common reasons to take out a personal loan:
- Debt consolidation: If you’ve acquired large amounts of high-interest credit card debt, consolidating the debt into a single personal loan may give you a lower interest rate and more favorable repayment terms. However, it is important to be responsible with future spending when using a loan for this purpose. “When considering a personal loan to pay off your debts, individuals should make sure they have dealt with their spending issues; otherwise, a personal loan might address short-term financial needs, but it is likely they’ll continue to dig themselves into deeper debt long-term,” says Steve Sexton, CEO of Sexton Advisory Group.
- Unexpected medical bills: A personal loan isn’t always recommended for paying off medical expenses. However, you may be offered lower rates and fees with a private lender than with your medical provider’s in-house financing options. Always consult with your medical provider to compare rates and fees before deciding to use a personal loan to pay off medical debt.
- Home improvement projects: A personal loan could be beneficial if you’re planning a home improvement project that will add value to your home. Plus, you don’t have to put your home up as collateral with an unsecured personal loan as you do with a home equity line of credit (HELOC) or home equity loan. However, a HELOC or home equity loan is often a better choice for this type of financial need.“In most cases, it makes more sense to look at a home equity line of credit because the interest rates are typically lower, payment terms are more flexible, and the borrower is able to write off the interest on your taxes,” says Sexton.
- Finance a wedding: Personal loans can finance weddings and other large events. Since the interest rates are lower than those of credit cards, you could save money in the long run.
Pros and cons of a personal loan
Knowing the pros and cons of a personal loan can help you make a well-informed decision before using this form of financing.
- Versatility: Personal loans can be used for almost any reason.
- A good option for debt consolidation: Personal loan interest rates are often lower than those of credit cards, so they may be a good option to consider when paying down credit card debt.
- Consistent monthly payments: The monthly payments are fixed, so you’ll be able to anticipate the amount and budget appropriately. “The payment amount can be adjusted [to fit your budget] based on the length of the loan and amount borrowed,” says Josh Simpson, vice president of operations and investment adviser with Lake Advisory Group. “The payments will always be the same as long as you have a fixed-rate loan and that will make it easier to budget your payments.”
- Potentially high interest rates: If you have poor credit, you may get stuck with high rates and fees. Because interest rates are at historic lows at the moment, some lenders are instituting prepayment penalties for those who pay off a loan before the end of the first year or two to ensure that they are able to make money when providing a loan, says Simpson.
- Added debt: If you are unable to make the payments on time, interest and late fees will accrue, making the loan harder to pay off.
How personal loans affect your credit
Depending on how you use a personal loan, it can have a positive or negative impact on your credit score. When you apply for your loan, a hard inquiry will be placed on your credit report, which can temporarily decrease your score by up to four points. However, If you pay your loan back on time, it could improve your credit score. Using a personal loan to consolidate high-interest debt may lower your credit utilization ratio — a key factor in determining your credit score — which could also improve your credit.
Before getting a personal loan, make sure you can pay it back on time. If you miss a payment, the lender may report it to one of the three major credit bureaus: Equifax, TransUnion or Experian. Because payment history accounts for 35 percent of your credit score, this can cause serious damage to your credit.
Who a personal loan is best for
If you have good to excellent credit and need to pay off a large expense or refinance high-interest debt, using a personal loan may be a wise financial choice. By using a personal loan instead of a credit card, you’ll likely pay less interest.
“Personal loans should be seen as a tool,” says Sexton. “A personal loan is for someone who needs a lump of money to pay off a debt that could be medical expense, credit card debt, or other loans. The personal loan strategy is designed to take pressure off the borrower when they have overspent. The best application will have a plan in place to pay off the debt.”
A personal loan works best if you can avoid late payment fees or damage to your credit score by making on-time monthly payments.
When to use a credit card
When it comes to credit card usage, paying your balance off in full at the end of the billing cycle is the most important thing you can do for your financial health. If you don’t pay your balance and your card doesn’t have a 0 percent introductory rate period, interest will accrue, meaning you may be paying that purchase off for a long time.
Because of this, you should only use your credit card for purchases that you’re certain you can pay off. Here are a few things you should use your credit card on:
- Smaller everyday purchases: A tank of gas or a cup of coffee are examples of purchases that are easier to pay off, helping you raise your credit score without putting you in deeper debt. “Small everyday purchases should be charged to a credit card. The reasoning is that if you are going to be making these purchases anyway if you use your credit for them and pay the charges off at the end of month, you can at least accrue reward points and cash back, if you have a credit card that offers these types of rewards,” says Adem Selita, CEO and co-founder of The Debt Relief Company .
- A well-planned vacation: If you have a travel credit card, you may be able to earn enough points to score a flight or a hotel room, though this perk does take planning and well-managed credit usage.
- Cash back opportunities: If you have a cash back card with rotating categories (like one from Discover), taking advantage of the quarterly rotating categories can earn you some lucrative cash back bonuses.
- 0 percent interest opportunity: If you have high-interest debt on one credit card, it might be best to transfer it to a card that has a 0 percent interest introductory rate. Just be mindful that you’ll likely incur a balance transfer fee. Also, make sure you can pay the balance off in full before the promotional rate expires.
When using a credit card may not be the best option
- Medical bills: If an unexpected medical expense comes your way, a personal loan may be a better idea. Personal loans tend to charge less interest than credit cards and can prevent high-interest debt in the future.
- Large purchases: Any larger purchase that you don’t see yourself paying off by the end of the billing cycle is generally not a purchase you should be making on your credit card. Due to the interest accrual, you could end up paying that purchase off for a while.
- Loans: It’s not recommended to use your credit card for paying loans off, especially student loans. You could be left with a higher interest accrual, which means that you could be paying that credit card debt down for much longer than the loan.
Pros and cons of a credit card
When used responsibly, a credit card can be a great way to earn rewards, cash back and travel benefits. However, a credit card does have the potential to negatively impact your financial health.
Here are some pros and cons that you’ll want to be aware of when considering a credit card.
- Earn rewards and bonuses: Depending on the card, you can earn cash back bonuses and rewards on the purchases you’re already making.
- Long-term benefits: Your credit score will determine your creditworthiness, which can dictate your interest rates and whether you’ll get approved for a loan. Making timely payments on your credit card is a great way to boost your credit score.
- Convenience: Carrying a credit card can be much more convenient than carrying cash. Plus, if something happens to your card or you misplace it, many issuers offer the option to temporarily freeze your account.
- Fraud protection: Credit cards are a good option when being used for everyday purchases, because they offer fraud protection. “If you have any fraudulent charges, you can call your card provider to dispute it and prevent funds from being taken,” says Selita.
- High interest rates: Since your rates are usually based on your creditworthiness, if you have less-than-stellar credit, you could end up with a high interest rate.
- Potential for more debt: If not used properly, a credit card could leave you stuck with debt that is difficult to pay down.
- Associated fees: There are numerous fees that can come with a credit card. For example, some hidden credit card fees include annual fees, late fees, foreign exchange fees and returned payment fees. Read the fine print of the card you’re considering.
How credit cards affect your credit
Credit cards are similar to personal loans in that they can have a positive or negative impact on your credit score. If you pay your credit card off on time each month, you’ll build up a history of on-time payments. Over time, this can increase your credit score.
If you don’t pay your credit card bill on time, you can damage your credit. Also, keeping a high balance on your card can lead to a high credit utilization ratio, which lowers your credit score. It’s typically a good idea to keep this ratio below 30 percent. For example, if you have $20,000 of credit available, you should use less than $6,000 of it to maintain a good credit score.
“If you utilize too much of your available credit, you will be viewed as highly dependent on credit and this will negatively impact your score,” says Selita. “However, the opposite is also true. If you have high credit limits and don’t often utilize the available credit, it’s a huge plus for your credit score.”
Finally, if you have long-established lines of credit cards that have been open for several years, this is viewed favorably by credit bureaus and can increase your credit score, particularly if you have consistently maintained the accounts in good standing.
If you need to make everyday purchases or you’re seeking to earn rewards, a credit card can be a better option than a personal loan.
“Credit cards are best for anyone looking to get cashback on daily purchases. I think everyone should use credit cards to maximize cash back and reward points,” says Selita. “However, the credit card must be used responsibly. If you cannot pay down the balance of any purchase at the end of the month, it really doesn’t belong on a credit card.”
Using a credit card can also be a better choice if you are able to qualify for a 0 percent interest rate. To qualify for the best rates, you’ll need to have good to excellent credit.
Alternatives to a personal loan or a credit card
Personal loans and credit cards aren’t the only ways to access funds. Below are a few options to consider:
- Home equity loan: A home equity loan allows you to borrow a lump sum of money by using the equity you’ve established in your home over time. You can use a home equity loan for a number of reasons, including home improvement projects and debt consolidation.
- HELOC: A HELOC also uses your home’s equity, but it works more like a credit card. With a HELOC, you’re given a line of credit and can take out how much you need, when you need it. They are best for ongoing home improvement projects or expenses.
- Personal line of credit: A personal line of credit is a type of personal loan that functions like a credit card. You can draw from the loan as you need it, and you’ll pay the balance back with interest. Common uses of a personal line of credit include funding unexpected expenses and major purchases.
- Cash advance: A cash advance is an option provided by many credit card issuers that allows you to withdraw cash against your credit card limit. The interest rate charged for a cash advance is typically higher than the interest charged for purchases, so always check your lender’s rates and fees before withdrawing.
Before getting a personal loan or credit card, it’s best to evaluate how it will impact your financial life. While a credit card is good for getting rewarded for making everyday purchases, it can lead to more debt if you buy things that don’t fit your budget. It works the same way with a personal loan — if you take out more than you can afford to, it can put you in a bad financial position.
Also, consider whether it is a smart idea to get a credit card or personal loan before making a large purchase. For example, if you’re in the process of applying for a mortgage, taking out a large personal loan could impact your ability to qualify for the mortgage.
Before you decide whether a personal loan or credit card is right for you, explore all of your options. Once you’ve made a decision, compare the rates and fees of each product. For example, if you decide to take out a personal loan, try prequalifying to compare rates from different lenders. If you choose a credit card, read the fine print to see if there are any hidden fees. Doing your research will help you determine which credit card or personal loan you should apply for and help you avoid any unnecessary fees.
Still have questions? Sign up for a Bankrate account to get answers from our team of money experts.