Dear Dr. Don,
I am considering refinancing my home. My wife and I are 52 and have a mortgage balance of $152,000 at 5.5 percent with 23 years remaining on the loan. Our home is worth about $300,000. We need to do some home improvements — new windows and a furnace. We’re having trouble deciding whether to go with a cash-out refinancing or a home equity loan.

It looks like we can refinance for about 4.375 percent with a 20-year mortgage, paying approximately $2,000 in closing costs. We would like to get about $20,000 for the improvements. Home equity loans seem to be about 5 percent to 7 percent right now.

It seems like a cash-out refinancing would save us thousands of dollars over the long term versus keeping our existing mortgage and getting a home equity loan. Can you please help us decide what to do?
— Richard Refi

Dear Richard,
It’s a fairly straightforward decision to do the cash-out refinancing: You can improve the interest rate on your existing first mortgage, shorten its term by three years and get a lower rate on the refinancing than you can on the home equity loan. Plus, the expected closing costs are only $2,000.

You’re looking to minimize total interest expense on an after-tax basis. At this writing, Bankrate’s national average for a home equity line of credit is 5.59 percent, and its national average for a home equity loan is 7.27 percent. The 4.375 percent mortgage rate on the cash-out refi trumps both of these rates.

I ran the numbers assuming that the HELOC was a self-amortizing loan, meaning the monthly payment was sized to pay off the loan over its 20-year term. Making interest-only payments in the early years of the HELOC would increase the total interest expense of the loan.

Bankrate’s refinance mortgage calculators can put a finer point on the interest savings for you.

Cash-out refinance vs. HELOC




HELOC Existing


Loan amount $172,000 $152,000 $20,000 $172,000
Loan term 240 months 276 months 240 months
Interest rate 4.375 percent 5.5 percent 5.59 percent
Monthly payment $1,076.59 $971.72 $138.60
Total interest $86,381 $116,194 $13,263 $129,457
Closing costs $2,000 $750 $750

As you can see, your total interest expense plus closing costs is about $42,000 less on a pretax basis than keeping your existing mortgage and financing the improvements with a HELOC. After-tax savings would be lower, but still would point to the cash-out refinancing.

Get more news, money-saving tips, and expert advice about mortgages and real estate by signing up for a free Bankrate newsletter.

Ask the adviser

To ask a question of Dr. Don, go to the “Ask the Experts” page, and select one of these topics: “Financing a home,” “Saving & Investing” or “Money.” Read more Dr. Don columns for additional personal finance advice.

Bankrate’s content, including the guidance of its advice-and-expert columns and this Web site, is intended only to assist you with financial decisions. The content is broad in scope and does not consider your personal financial situation. Bankrate recommends that you seek the advice of advisers who are fully aware of your individual circumstances before making any final decisions or implementing any financial strategy. Please remember that your use of this Web site is governed by Bankrate’s Terms of Use.