In the wake of all the economic carnage unleashed by COVID-19, many companies have cut not only jobs but also benefits such as the company match on 401(k) retirement plans. Even if you’re employed, you may still have to deal with reduced benefits for a while, as companies regain their financial footing.
“With more employers suspending retirement benefits and company matches, consumers are facing greater financial responsibility for how to save for the future and act in their own best interests,” says Pam Krueger, CEO of Wealthramp in the San Francisco area.
While experts generally recommend saving as much as you can in your 401(k) plan, you’ll want to consider many other options in these exceptional times, including not contributing at all. Here’s what to do if you lose your 401(k) employer match and what alternatives you may have.
How 401(k) matching contributions work
The 401(k) plan is one of the most popular retirement savings programs in the U.S., and the company match is one of the easiest ways for workers to quickly accumulate extra retirement funds. Workers contribute directly from their paychecks, and the company contributes additional funds, often as much as 3 to 5 percent of the worker’s salary each year, depending on the plan.
Some employers require that matching contributions vest over time, usually three to four years. Often each year a portion of the employer match vests, giving you legal ownership of it. So you may not have a full claim on the matching contribution until a few years have passed.
A 2019 study by Natixis Investment Managers of 700 workers with defined contribution plans such as a 401(k) found that the top reason (56 percent) for participating was the company match. And 57 percent said that a larger match would incentivize them to save more.
Assess your financial picture
It’s definitely a shame if your company cuts its matching funds. But if it has, you’ll want to do two things at first:
- Determine why the company cut the match and its overall financial health.
- Assess your own financial health.
By looking at these two factors you’ll get a better read on what kinds of actions are best for you.
“First, is your company healthy enough to survive this period,” says Nicholas Stuller, founder at MyPerfectFinancialAdvisor in West Cornwall, Connecticut.
Did the company cut its matching plan because it’s in serious financial trouble that it’s unlikely to recover from, or is the problem more short-term in nature?
But you’ll also want to get a read on your own personal finances. Could you muddle through if one spouse lost a job? Do you have money stashed away in an emergency fund such as a high-yield savings account – not the stock market – that is risk-free and easily accessible?
What actions you can take
Depending on your assessment, you may have several courses of action. Importantly, continuing to contribute to your retirement plan won’t always be the best path to take. It’s critical to make it through to the other side of tough times without ruining your financial health. Taking on loads of debt during a downturn may hurt your long-term future more than not saving for a year or two.
“If your company has simply decided to no longer match funds, then there’s nothing you have to do,” says Michelle Sloan Jones, chief external affairs officer of Money Management International, a nonprofit in financial education in the Atlanta area.
1. When your company is in poor financial shape
If your company is not healthy, Stuller recommends looking to shore up your own personal financial and career situation before worrying about retirement, a move that others echo.
One of the first options is getting your emergency fund in order while you can. Experts recommend having at least six months of expenses on hand, but in tougher times having more is not going to hurt you. You can always return to contributing to your retirement accounts later.
“If you are already struggling to make ends meet or are uncertain about the security of your job, put more cash into a liquid savings account instead,” says Laura Hearn, CFP, a wealth advisor at RMB Capital in Chicago. “Why? If you increase the savings to your 401(k) and find yourself crunched for cash, tapping into your 401(k) savings can be costly.”
Hearn notes that 401(k) withdrawals will incur a 10 percent bonus penalty on top of any taxes already due on distributions, if you’re under age 59 1/2.
“If you can’t make up for the lost match this year due to uncertainty of cash flow, don’t fret,” says Hearn. “One year of not having a company match savings is unlikely to derail your long-term financial plan.”
From here you can then think about the next best move, both financially and career-wise.
2. When your company appears relatively stable or healthy
If the company and your personal situation are stable, then you’ll have more options. But even then you may still want to shore up your finances before you commit to further retirement savings. From there you have a few avenues you can consider.
“If [your company] is healthy, then can you afford to personally make up the match and continue to save? If so, do it,” says Stuller. “Consider paring back other expenses to re-allocate those monies to savings if you can.”
But without the match, workers are missing out on one of the most important benefits of a workplace retirement plan.
“Continuing to contribute to your retirement is highly recommended but, without an employer match, the only real benefit to staying with your employer’s plan is convenience,” says Jones.
Still it can make sense to stay in your employer’s plan for other reasons, such as a good selection of funds and the convenience of having money invested straight from your paycheck.
“If the company has promised to restore the match in the near future, it may be in your best interest to stay put,” says Jones. “But if not, assessing plan performance should be your next step. If you find stronger performance and better gains elsewhere, you can always choose to voluntarily move the funds.”
On the one hand you can roll that 401(k) money into an IRA – either traditional or Roth IRA – but you’ll want to understand the advantages and disadvantages of such a move. But you have other alternatives to your company’s 401(k) plan, and even a taxable brokerage account could be a good option if you need penalty-free access to your money.
On the other hand, don’t be in such a hurry to move the money, if the company is in otherwise solid shape, as experience from the last recession shows.
“Remember, employers by and large returned to making matches once the economy recovered,” says Steve Parrish, co-director of the Center for Retirement Income at the non-profit American College of Financial Services in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania.
Should you always contribute to your 401(k)?
If your job and personal finances look secure, then adding to your retirement savings is a great option. Some experts recommend always opting for retirement savings.
“The most important step consumers can take is to continue contributing to their retirement plan because contributions are automated and therefore help you to systematically invest,” says Krueger. “Then there’s the benefit of tax deferral on those 401(k) contributions.”
“Call it behavioral finance or human nature: If you continue to contribute, you’re less likely to touch your savings,” says Parrish.
By keeping up the commitment to your retirement account, you’ll tend to see it as untouchable money that must be maintained for your future, allowing the money to compound tax-free over many years.
Still, you have to balance the future against your present needs.
Other alternatives to consider
Sometimes in personal finance there may not always be a trade-off for a decision. That might be the case now with low mortgage rates. If your financial situation is strong – and maybe even if it isn’t – you may be able to take advantage of historically low mortgage rates to refinance.
“Perhaps the best way to take advantage of these record-low interest rates is not within a 401(k),” says Tim Shaler, economist in residence at iTrustCapital in Encino, California. “As soon as the Fed and Treasury actions in the mortgage market normalizes originators’ ability to help borrowers, everyone who can save money should refi their mortgage on their homes.”
The savings there could total hundreds of dollars a month alone, depending on the size of your loan. Any money could then be rolled into savings, either to bolster your emergency fund or allowing you to add more into your 401(k). In effect, you can create your own match via savings.
“I’d also encourage consumers to look for every dime of benefits at work you may be ignoring, like health savings accounts (HSA),” says Krueger. “These are triple tax-advantaged accounts that can be used for qualifying medical costs in retirement and you don’t lose the funds like flexible spending accounts (FSA).”
Contributing to your retirement savings – and your future financial security – is important, but you’ll want to carefully assess your own financial situation to see if continuing your contributions during uncertain times really does make sense for you. If it doesn’t, shore up your finances and then return to your retirement savings as soon as it does make sense for you to do so.
“Most importantly, 401(k) investors are reminded to ‘know thyself’ — what are your goals, what is your situation and what kind of volatility comes with your return requirements,” says Shaler.