Homeowner associations: Devils or angels?

"Almost all new development in densely-populated areas is CIDs. It is a total transformation of the landscape of American home ownership," says McKenzie. "The traditional family home is becoming extinct in larger cities."

Is this a bad thing? "It is for homeowners who are sacrificing privacy, control and freedom of choice," says watchdog Hyland, director of the National Institute of Community Management, in Phoenix.

When you move into a CID, Hyland explained, you automatically become a member of the association and are bound to certain deed restrictions, covenants and conditions.

They include the association's regulations, and require that every owner be a member of the association and abide by its rules.

"The point of the rules is to protect the community, and to maintain or improve property values," says Hyland.

"When you join a homeowners association, you are signing a contract," says McKenzie, who teaches a course on condo law at John Marshall Law School, Chicago. "These are legally-binding covenants and if you don't want to live by them you should not buy the house.

"You're handing over control of the way you want your home to look, and what you want to do in and around it to the association's board of directors. They can be untrained people with no knowledge of the law or business, and sometimes have very bizarre ideas of what they want in their community.

"Most associations do well, and protect residents' interests, but there are some horror stories out there. Even when you have a board filled with great people, it's still only one election away from disaster!"

Some love it, some don't

Ironically, the very aspects of safety and tidy appearance, which attract people to CID living, are made possible by tight enforcement of rules that many residents find irksome.

Typical CID rules prohibit or limit the use of such things as flags, clotheslines, wind chimes, signs on your lawn or in your window, garage sales and the presence of pets.

How many cars you can have and where you may park is a popular bone of contention, but the rules can get far more intrusive.

One HOA told a woman to remove the small Cleveland Indians sticker she'd put on her mailbox, another objected to a 'Peace' sign in a window. Some dictate when you can put out the garbage, and what flowers you may plant, others restrict remodeling projects.

Repainting? Invariably, you must take your proposed new paint scheme before the committee -- and pay a fee for their consideration.

Unruly behavior or noise is banned. One man was fined because his too-large flag flapped at night. An elderly lady was fined by her HOA for sitting outside her Missouri home in her car and kissing her retiree beau.

"Nobody should have the authority these boards have over what people own," says Elizabeth McMahon, co-founder of the American Homeowners' Resource Center, a consumer group in San Juan Capistrano, Calif.

Another area of great concern, says McKenzie, is property maintenance.

"Many CIDs are 20 or more years old. Typically, the developer's responsibility has ended, so, when roofs start to leak or streets to break down, the homeowners have to finance repairs.

"The associations should have reserves to pay for that, but the developers almost always set maintenance fees very low to help them sell units, and the associations invariably find themselves under funded."

To raise the needed funds, the HOAs levy hefty special assessments and often hike the monthly fees to create future reserves.

Despite the horror stories and the legions of critics, it's obvious many Americans appreciate the way HOAs operate. Why else would 20 per cent of the population voluntarily place themselves under their control? One man's trash is another's treasure -- or in this case, one man's devil is another's angel.

The choice is yours. But make it only after you've thoroughly investigated what you're getting yourself into.


Show Bankrate's community sharing policy
          Connect with us

Timely market news and advice for consumers ready to buy, sell or invest in real estate. Delivered weekly.


Greg McBride

Greg McBride: Lay down ARMs?

Don't rule out adjustable-rate mortgages as interest rates rise.  ... Read more

Partner Center

Connect with us