real estate

Shares in a co-op unaffected by the market

Steve McLindenq_v2.gifDear Real Estate Adviser,
I am a potential first-time homebuyer interested in a co-op located just a few blocks from where I work. Because a co-op is actually a stock purchase, I am concerned that buying one is riskier than a condo, given all the stock-market trouble. If there's a stock market crash, wouldn't the stock be affected? I'd hate to get wiped out and end up homeless!

a_v2.gifDear James,
Fret not. While you would be buying shares of a corporation that owns the co-op building, that corporation is not a publicly owned entity and thus is not subject to the turbulence of the stock market.

In a co-op, short for cooperative housing project, you aren't purchasing a unit in a given housing complex as you would with a condominium. Rather, you are purchasing the above-mentioned shares that give you a proprietary lease in the building. It's also known as a "membership." The larger your living unit, the more shares you own in the corporation. Most co-op corporations, by the way, have not-for-profit structures. But as part of your share purchase, you will have a vote in the affairs of the co-op corporation.

Because you are technically buying shares of a corporation instead of actual real estate, you will likely need to request what's called a "share loan" from your lender. A lender usually wants to see a minimum-occupancy figure in the co-op building exceeding 50 percent before they will make such a loan.

Every month, you would be paying an amount covering your lease, or "share," to that lender, plus making a separate payment to the co-op covering your portion of the facility's monthly operating expenses. Those expenses typically include the blanket mortgage payment on the property, maintenance, property tax, insurance, utilities and management fees, plus a preset contribution to the co-op's reserve, or "rainy day" fund.

Make sure you clearly understand your financial obligations before buying into a cooperative. While you don't accumulate equity in a co-op, most co-op corporations have a market-rate structure that allows you, with some minimum-stay restrictions, to sell your shares for what the market will bear. Realize, too, that co-op boards frown on subletting units more than condo boards. For more on the merits and differences of co-ops and condos, see a previous column.

So, no, the New York Stock Exchange can tank precipitously without wiping out your co-op shares and rendering you homeless. But realize that if real-estate values fall, so will the share value of your stake in the co-op.

Good luck with your new co-op home and enjoy that short walk to work.


          Connect with us


Stephen Pounds

Existing home sales slump in July

Exist home sales fell for the first time since March and decreased year over year for the first time since November 2015, the NAR study shows.  ... Read more


Connect with us