Dear Tax Talk,
We are in the process of being foreclosed upon on my primary home and our one and only rental house. Our tax adviser said that we may be able to claim insolvency. Otherwise we will probably owe taxes on the rental house.
Can you explain what insolvency is? Is our 401(k) balance included in our assets? Thank you.
While your creditors may not have access to your retirement accounts, the IRS does. The general rule is that if you have a debt that is forgiven, you recognize income. Exceptions exist for primary home debt forgiven as well as debts forgiven in bankruptcy proceedings and when a taxpayer is insolvent.
The cancellation of your primary home debt is not considered income provided that the debt was used to purchase the home and was not increased by a cash-out refinance.
Ideally you, just like everyone else in your situation, would like to avoid filing bankruptcy to avoid further embarrassment and credit damage. If you could avail yourself of the insolvency exception to avoid recognizing income from the rental property’s debt discharge, you would be able to avoid bankruptcy.
It is a long-established principle of taxation that a discharge of debt results in a gain to the debtor. The reasoning is that when the loan originated, you didn’t recognize income because you’re obligated to repay it. If you don’t repay it, you have somehow gained. Many people in foreclosure don’t feel like they’ve gained anything. However, the bank’s loss was caused by your mistake in investment and when the bank isn’t repaid, you’re being held accountable for its loss.
For many years, the tax law has given bankrupt and insolvent taxpayers a break when it comes to forgiven debt. The reasoning is that the tax law shouldn’t take a bad situation and make it worse. It’s pretty well established that if you enter into bankruptcy, certain assets, depending on your state of residency, are exempt from creditor claims. Generally, these assets are homestead property, insurance products and retirement accounts. What had not been clear is how these assets were treated in the case of insolvency; neither the law, IRS regulations, announcements or rulings explained it.
A taxpayer in bankruptcy proceedings can exclude forgiven debt from income. A taxpayer that is insolvent can also exclude forgiven debt from income to the extent insolvent. Insolvency means that a person’s liabilities exceed their assets. Hence, the definition of assets is extremely important in determining the extent to which a person is insolvent.
Prior to the real estate crisis, the IRS took a taxpayer’s claim of insolvency to tax court. The taxpayers sought to exclude assets exempt from creditor’s claims when measuring insolvency. The theory being that if the assets are exempt in bankruptcy proceedings, the taxpayer shouldn’t be forced into bankruptcy just for the favorable tax consequences. The IRS and the U.S. Tax Court couldn’t have disagreed more.
Hence, in determining the extent of your insolvency, you will have to count your 401(k) as an asset. I recommend you have your tax adviser work out the consequences more concisely so that you can measure the benefit of declaring bankruptcy.
Ask the adviser
To ask a question on Tax Talk, go to the “Ask the Experts” page and select “Taxes” as the topic. Read more Tax Talk columns.
To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein. Taxpayers should seek professional advice based on their particular circumstances.