Bankate.com
 
News and AdviceCompare RatesCalculators
Glossary  |  Help  
 
 
- advertisement -
 
Columns: Driving for Dollars
Terry Jackson Expert: Terry Jackson
Driving for Dollars
Better-built cars are good for consumers but bad for dealers
Driving for Dollars

Dealers now vie for oil, brake and tire jobs
 

It may seem counterintuitive, but as cars get better, dealers make less money.

- advertisement -

The most recent J.D. Power and Associates Initial Quality Study shows cars are continuing to get better and show fewer problems when delivered to customers. That means the dealer knows there is going to be less manufacturer-paid warranty work and that once a car leaves the showroom floor it's possible the dealership will never see that customer again.

But what's not-so-good for the dealers seems to be working out well for consumers.

To make up for the loss of warranty work, many savvy dealerships are trying to lure back customers for non-warranty work, such as oil changes, routine brake service, new batteries and even replacement tire sales.

And when warranty work is required, another J.D. Power survey shows, dealerships are making a greater push to make sure repairs are done right the first time.

This push toward customer satisfaction by some dealers appears to be working.

In a survey this year of 84,485 owners of cars ranging in age from 2004 to 2006 models, 52 percent returned to dealerships for non-warranty service, up from 49 percent in 2004.

Those customers who paid for the work out of their own pocket gave their dealerships higher marks for quality of service than those who had factory-paid warranty work done, but both scores showed improvement from previous years' surveys.

The dealership brands that ranked highest in the survey were Jaguar, Buick, Cadillac, Lexus and Mercury, in that order. At the bottom of the heap was Isuzu,  followed by Suzuki, Volkswagen, Land Rover and Jeep.

Owners cited many factors on why they thought they did or didn't get satisfactory service, but among the reasons cited was honest communication between the customer and the service representatives.

Another reason owners may be turning toward dealerships for non-warranty work is the increasing complexity of today's vehicles and a feeling that a neighborhood repair shop may not be up to snuff on the latest technology.

So how should a consumer decide whether to go to a dealer or take their car elsewhere?

For fairly routine work such as oil changes, most dealers are competitive with independent shops and many dealers also offer the same quick service.

For other types of work, check the dealer's hourly rate versus other shops. While there was a time when hourly rates at dealerships were far above independent shops, the playing field has leveled somewhat as shops have had to invest in new equipment and hire more skilled workers.

Consumers should also check for some other perks, such as free loaner cars and free washing of your car after service.

In the end, what it may come down to is a feeling of trust that your car will be fixed properly and at a fair price.

As with the process of buying a car, doing your homework is paramount. But don't immediately discard those overtures from your dealer to come on back.

This week
Dealers vie for oil, brake and tire jobs
Why does my new car have no sticker?
Why is the paint flaking off my Cavalier?
Why would truck be repossessed after lease is over?
Bankrate.com's corrections policy-- Posted: Aug. 25, 2007
Read more Driving for Dollars columns
Ask a question

Auto Loans
Compare today's rates
NATIONAL OVERNIGHT AVERAGES
48 month new car loan 6.75%
60 month new car loan 6.56%
48 month used car loan 6.80%
ADVERTISING PARTNERS
RELATED CALCULATORS
  Auto loan calculator  
  A rebate or special dealer financing?  
  How much will the auto lease really cost?  
VIEW ALL  
SAVE YOUR HOME
Struggling to pay your mortgage? Read this.
- advertisement -
 
- advertisement -


News & Advice | Compare Rates | Calculators
Mortgage | Home Equity | Auto | Investing | Checking & Savings | Credit Cards | Debt Management | College Finance | Taxes | Personal Finance
About Bankrate | Privacy | Online Media Kit | Partnerships | Investor Relations | Press/Broadcast | Contact Us | Sitemap
NASDAQ: RATE | RSS Feeds | Order Rate Data | Bankrate Canada | Bankrate China

* Mortgage rate may include points. See rate tables for details. Click here.
* To see the definition of overnight averages click here.

Bankrate.com ®, Copyright © 2008 Bankrate, Inc., All Rights Reserved, Terms of Use.