Skip to Main Content

Higher Earners, Low-Debt and Conventional Borrowers More Likely to Overpay for Mortgages

October 5, 2026

New Bankrate data finds some of the most financially qualified borrowers are among the most likely to overpay, costing between $52,108 and $92,338 over the life of a 30-year mortgage


NEW YORK — October 5, 2026 — A new Bankrate report shows borrowers earning between $100,000 and $199,000 annually, borrowers with lower debt balances, older borrowers (55+) and conventional-loan borrowers are more likely to overpay for their mortgages by not securing the best available rate.

Bankrate’s team of consumer advocates compiled this research and additional information can be found at: https://www.bankrate.com/mortgages/where-homebuyers-overpay-mortgages/

Overpaying is widespread nationally, with 87% of all mortgage borrowers overpaying, according to Bankrate’s Hidden Homeownership Tax report. Overpayments add excessive costs to homebuying and are driven by a lack of comparison shopping; such as relying on referrals or existing lender relationships, or prioritizing convenience.

To determine what demographics are overpaying the most, Bankrate compared 3.2 million HMDA mortgage loan originations from 2025 and compared them against binding, competitive offers available on Bankrate’s marketplace.

“Some of the most qualified mortgage borrowers are leaving the most money on the table,” said Bankrate Data Analyst Alex Gailey. “Great credit, a higher income and a conventional loan don’t guarantee the best mortgage rate. Only shopping around does, and too many people skip that step.”

Households earning between $100,000 to $199,000 have the highest likelihood of mortgage overpayment at 90%, followed closely by those earning $200,000 to $499,000 at 89%. By comparison, 82% of households earning under $50,000 overpay. Over the life of a 30-year mortgage, six-figure earners pay an average of $82,323 to $192,626 in excess costs.

Among those with debt-to-income ratios between 33.1% and 38%, 92% overpay, followed by 91% of borrowers with DTIs between 10% and 33%. Those with the highest DTIs, between 45.1% and 65%, have the lowest overpayment rate at 85%. Average lifetime overpayments across these groups range from $69,256 to $92,338.

Conventional-loan borrowers are also more likely to overpay than the general population, at 89% compared with 87%. By comparison, 83% of FHA borrowers and 81% of VA borrowers overpay. Average lifetime overpayments are $53,350 for FHA borrowers; $67,090 for VA borrowers; and $86,197 for conventional borrowers.

Eighty-one percent of older mortgage borrowers, 55+, are overpaying, costing nearly $2,379 per year, which can add up to $52,108 over a 30-year repayment period.

Overpayment rate Average annual overpayment Average 8-year overpayment Average lifetime overpayment
Borrowers earning $100k-$199k 90% $3,551 $28,406 $82,323
Borrowers with lower debt-to-income ratio (33.1% to 38%) 92% $3,876 $31,010 $92,338
Conventional loan borrowers 89% $3,599 $28,791 $86,197
Refinancers ages 55+ 81% $2,379 $19,034 $52,108

“Too many borrowers take the first ‘good enough’ rate they’re offered, and it can cost them tens of thousands of dollars over 30 years, especially with mortgages above 7%,” Gailey said. “Getting a few competing quotes takes an afternoon, and it can be one of the best money-saving moves in the homebuying process.”

Methodology

Bankrate analyzed 3.2 million HMDA mortgage loan originations from 2025 and compared them against binding, competitive offers available on Bankrate’s marketplace to determine which borrowers are most likely to overpay for their mortgage.

To ensure a fair and accurate comparison, our analysis controlled for 17 different factors that can influence loan pricing. Once loans were compared across datasets, we calculated the probability that borrowers are overpaying (%) and average overpayment amounts ($) over one year, 8 years and 30 years.

For more detailed information on the methodology and the analysis, see Bankrate’s research on the Hidden Homeownership Tax.

About Bankrate

Bankrate is where Americans go to get the best price on life’s most important financial decisions. By combining proprietary data, advanced technology, and deep market coverage, Bankrate helps consumers compare options and make confident financial choices across mortgages, credit cards, savings, and more. As a rate provider to the Federal Reserve and the benchmark relied upon by major publishers and policymakers nationwide, Bankrate’s rate data is the national standard. This commitment to precision is reflected across all its products. In mortgages, proprietary auction technology puts lenders in real-time competition on price alone, consistently delivering rates in the lowest 10% in the country. For deposits, the platform features exclusively top-tier rates in the top 10% nationally, while its credit card coverage encompasses more than 90% of the market by volume. Founded by a journalist, Bankrate remains dedicated to its founding mission of transparency, honest information, and real competition — helping to make the American dream more affordable for everyone.

Bankrate, LLC NMLS ID# 1427381 | NMLS Consumer Access
BR Tech Services, Inc. NMLS ID #1743443 | NMLS Consumer Access

For more information:

Alexandria Cremer
Public Relations Manager, Bankrate
acremer@bankrate.com | 704.426.3684