What is a short sale?
Selling a home for less than the amount the current owner owes the mortgage company is called a short sale. Buying a home that is a short sale is different from buying a property that is actually owned by the bank, known as an REO, or real-estate owned property, or a property that is in foreclosure.
This spring, real estate sales began picking up in many U.S. markets as buyers snatched up homes at depressed price levels. But not all sales have been proceeding smoothly. As a rule, sales involving foreclosures and short sales take longer than usual to close because of their inherent complexity.
Still, they represent a significant portion of sales activity. In February, these transactions made up 45 percent to 50 percent of all sales, sometimes more in parts of the country where the foreclosure rates were particularly high, according to the National Association of Realtors.
How can you get in on a good short-sale deal? It takes a certain amount of fortitude and patience, plus a lot of luck.
RATE SEARCH: Don’t miss a short sale opportunity. Get prequalified for a mortgage today
Finding a good deal
A short sale can be a good deal for a buyer, and it can help the seller avoid having a full foreclosure on his or her credit record. Although a short sale and a foreclosure negatively affect a seller’s credit score, in a short sale the damage can be minimized if the homeowner can persuade the lender to report the debt to credit bureaus as “paid in full.”
In a short sale, the proceeds from the transaction are less than the amount the seller needs to pay the mortgage debt and the costs of selling. For this deal to close, everyone who is owed money must agree to take less — or possibly no money at all. That makes short sales complex transactions that move slowly and often fall through.
A recently announced extension of the government’s housing rescue plan could make it easier to buy short-sale properties. The new version of the Making Home Affordable plan will pay lenders up to $1,000 if they allow a short sale of a property when the owners don’t qualify for loan modification because they owe too much money on the home. The program will spell out a short-sale process and provide standard documents, the U.S. Treasury says.
The government’s plan probably still won’t help if there are multiple liens on the property, but it should encourage lenders holding the first mortgage to move the process along.
Keep your eyes wide open
If you’re house hunting and spot what seems like a great deal, chances are good that you are considering a short-sale property.
Most of the time, the seller has already fallen behind on the mortgage, but occasionally the seller is current but unable to continue to pay because of ill health or job change. This is particularly true in parts of the country where home prices have fallen significantly.
Before you rush in, consider the issues. The advice below comes from Scott Thompson, senior vice president of Mortgage Resolution Services, a distressed sales consulting company, and Vicki Vidal, associate vice president of government affairs for the Mortgage Bankers Association.
Know what you are getting into. Under the best circumstances, short sales take a long time to close and may require extra effort on the part of the buyer. Walking blindly into a short sale can be a losing and distressing proposition, so push for disclosure before you get involved, Thompson says.
This is not a do-it-yourself project. Find a real estate professional who understands the territory. Having a real estate agent on your side who knows how short sales work and who has negotiated others will increase the chances of closing the deal.
“I would ask the agent to provide references, specifically on an REO or a property that was in short sale,” Thompson says. “You certainly don’t want someone who is a shrinking violet.”
Thompson and Vidal advise staying away from “short-sale counselors,” those who say they can jump in and expedite the deal. Their game often involves negotiating a low price with the lender, charging the buyer more money — often significantly more money — and pocketing the difference. This “counselor” probably won’t make the deal go any more smoothly for you and certainly won’t do you any favors pricewise.
Be wary of the condition of the property. If the seller is in financial distress, chances are the home may not be well-preserved. The seller also may be reluctant to reveal serious maintenance issues. Proceed cautiously and get the property inspected by a knowledgeable person before you commit.
Make sure the deal has a prayer of closing
If you’ve decided to go for it, the first step is to have your real estate agent talk to the real estate agent representing the seller and determine the status of the short sale. Below are items that most lenders require from a short seller. If the seller is unable or unwilling to provide this information, the short sale won’t close and any buyer is wasting his or her time. Your real estate agent should push for candor from the seller’s agent.
- A hardship letter. The seller must explain why he or she cannot continue making payments. The sadder the story, the better. A seller who is simply tired of struggling probably won’t be approved, but a seller with cancer, no job and an empty bank account may.
- Proof of income and assets. If the seller has money in the bank, including retirement funds, it is unlikely that the lender will let the debt slide. This package of information must include income tax and bank statements, going back at least two years. Sometimes sellers are unwilling to produce these documents because they conflict with information on the original loan application, which may have been fudged. If that’s the case, this deal is unlikely to close.
- Comparative market analysis. This document shows that the price of the property has declined and that the property won’t sell anytime soon for the amount owed. This packet of information should include a list of comparable properties on the market and a list of properties that have sold in the past six months or have been on the market in that time frame and are about to close. This packet of information is similar to what’s known as a Broker Price Opinion, which is less formal but often more informative than a property appraisal. The prices should support the seller’s contention that the property is worth no more than the short-sale price.
- A list of liens. There may be more than one, so determine how many liens are on the property. The good news is that since late 2008, the IRS has been willing to release a federal tax lien. The IRS is not forgiving the back taxes that homeowners owe; it is just no longer requiring that the lien be paid off before the property can be sold. And a single mortgage lien is an easy problem to solve.
If there are first and second mortgage liens, the question becomes: What’s the plan to satisfy these lien holders? The seller and the real estate agent should have a plan that is more sophisticated than crossing their fingers, Thompson says. In the best of all possible worlds, the seller will be willing to contribute to paying off the second lien, so the first lien holder gets the full amount from the sale.
If there is a third mortgage lien, reaching any deal is very iffy. Deal killers include child support liens, state tax liens and homeowners association liens. If they exist and there are no obvious solutions, walk away, Thompson says.
Here’s one more deal killer, something that can be difficult to sleuth out, says Thompson. Because a short sale generally doesn’t cover the whole amount owed or other liens, it can trigger mortgage insurance. If the property is covered by a mortgage insurance policy that doesn’t have to pay off until the home has been in foreclosure for 150 days or some similar length of time, chances are the insurer will hold up the sale because it won’t want to pay any earlier than necessary and hopes the foreclosure will just disappear. Often the mortgage insurer will simply go silent. Thompson says: No response, no approval. (Bankrate offers several articles on the topic of foreclosure.)
The bottom line: Don’t choose a short sale if you’re in a hurry.
“It’s a waiting game,” says Vidal.
Part of what slows down short sales is buyers’ insistence on making really lowball offers, she says. “You get really crazy, ridiculously low offers — and they are rejected.”
Another factor is the increasing number of government programs aimed at keeping people in their homes — about 50 percent of defaults never go as far as foreclosure, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association. So lenders see short sales as potentially the least attractive option and aren’t willing to expedite them.
How can a potential short-sale buyer be protected from getting involved in an extended negotiation that doesn’t go anywhere in the end? Thompson says you should negotiate an agreement with the seller and the seller’s real estate agent that your offer will be the only one presented to the lender. If the lender isn’t flooded with offers, it will be more motivated to move forward. If the lender turns down the offer without countering, then the restriction disappears.
Once you’ve crafted a deal, you better know where the money is coming from to close. If you’re getting a loan, you need bank approval in advance.
As is true with any of these deals — REOs, short sales, foreclosure auctions — make sure you have money lined up. Cash is the best financing alternative in these cases.