"Ever since the end of 2008, the landscape has changed. I don't think you should just buy everything like an ETF does -- it buys a sector; it buys an index, in most cases," Wolfe says.
The firm Standard and Poor's tracks the performance of actively managed funds versus indexes in its S&P Indices Versus Active Funds U.S. Scorecard and finds that the only category that shows persistent outperformance over time by active managers is the international small-cap equity sector. In the short-term, any number of sectors might do better than their benchmark indexes or they could all do worse. Consistently picking the right sector and fund is where advisers can earn their fees.
Wolf says benchmark outperformance can be found in "certain sectors in the mid-size area and the small-size area and some international … but in big companies -- IBM, Intel, the biggest 100 out there -- you probably don't need to spend the money on a manager," he says. You could "just buy the index."
Mutual funds offer unique strategies
Mutual funds lend themselves more to unique investing strategies such as target-date funds. These are often designed as funds of funds with active strategies. Meanwhile, target-date ETFs tend to follow indexes.
"In some cases, ETFs just don't provide people with enough," says Robert Stammers, CFA, director of investor education at the CFA Institute.
"If you find a strategy that is unique and you find valuable, that might be a consideration" in favor of choosing a mutual fund, he says.
Target-date ETFs have another drawback as well: trading costs. Commissions will seriously erode returns when investors put money into a retirement account and dollar-cost average into ETFs over the span of many years.
No commissions with mutual funds
Many mutual funds are available with no transaction fees and no sales commissions. On the ETF side, buying or selling most ETFs does incur a trading commission. That can make ETFs less than ideal for investors who are making regular contributions of small amounts of money.
"If your commission is $7 or $8 and you're only buying $500 of the investment, that is a big chunk of your total investment," says Elliott Orsillo, CFA, co-founder of Season Investments in Colorado Springs, Colorado. "In that case, it's better to use a mutual fund," he says.
What would you choose: ETF or mutual fund?
Assume someone invests $500 on a biweekly basis in both an ETF and a mutual fund. Both investments get 8 percent annual returns net of their expense ratio. The only difference is that the investor pays an $8 commission biweekly with the ETF. After 10 years, this is what the investor has accumulated in the two funds:
On the flip side, ETFs allow investors to buy very small portions of the investment, which has benefits for investors who are just starting out with a small account.
"Since they trade like shares, you don't have to have a minimum investment. It doesn't make sense to buy one share of an ETF, but with many mutual funds you need $10,000 or more as a minimum initial investment," says Stammers.
"So it's harder to get diversity with mutual funds; you may not be able to spread money around as well as you could using ETFs," he says.
These small investors could avoid commissions altogether by seeking out no-commission ETFs.
ETFs offer tax efficiency
Mutual funds can be expensive when it comes to taxes. Even if the mutual fund isn't trading a bunch of stocks as part of its strategy, the act of simply redeeming shares for outgoing investors can force managers to sell shares of the investments in the fund. Any taxes incurred from the sale are paid by shareholders at the end of the year. Even if you buy the fund late in the year, you could still be paying a tax bill for events that happened before you made the investment, thanks to what are known as embedded gains.
What are Exchange Traded Funds?
"You could buy a mutual fund today and lose $1,000. Let's say you lose 10 percent. You could still have taxable gain at the end of the year. You're inheriting the tax basis in those shares when you buy into a mutual fund. It may have fallen 10 percent after you bought in, but it may have been up 40 percent up prior to that," Wolfe says.
"ETFs work more like stocks and your tax basis is whatever your tax basis is, not the ETF's tax basis," he says.
But taxes may not be the first thing to consider when choosing an investment.
"One thing we advise investors is never let the tax efficiency drive the investment decision," says Stammers. Instead, ask yourself: "What is the right strategy and what are you buying the product for?" he says.
The tax concern is a moot point when purchasing mutual funds within a tax-favorable retirement vehicle such as a 401(k) or an IRA, in which gains are not taxed.