Now, the big question: What do you want to do with it? Grill hot dogs for two on warm summer evenings? Fire it up on July Fourth and feed the whole neighborhood? Do you want to smoke that Thanksgiving turkey? Or roast a whole chicken on a spit?
Make a list of the things you want to do and refer to it when you compare grills. Is it made for this purpose? Does it come with all the necessary equipment or will you need extra parts? Will the job be easy or difficult with this grill? How does it compare to others for this particular job? Chances are, one model will have more of what you want.
The main thing to look for "is the ability to cook at a wide range of temperatures, just like you want in your kitchen," says Bill Jamison, co-author of "Good Times, Good Grilling," with his wife, Cheryl. For smoking, you want low, controlled heat. To get that backyard barbecue flavor for steaks and burgers, you want really high heat.
While many grills will boast high heat, opt for one that will give you those temperatures with the lid open. "That's the only way you apply direct heat," says Bill Jamison.
While some barbecue aficionados look at the BTU usage to measure potential heat, Cheryl Jamison believes that's just one factor. "The main thing that makes a difference is the closeness of the source of heat to the cooking grate," she says.
Bill Jamison agrees. "That's an indication that you're going to get higher heat." Another indicator is an infrared burner. All infrared or a combination of gas and infrared "means you're going to have a high searing capability," he says.
On the other hand, if the flame is "eight or nine inches from the grate and there is no infrared, I would insist on seeing it in operation and doing a hand test," he says.
Put your hand two to three inches above the cooking grate and see how long it takes for the fire to force you to pull your hand away, says Bill Jamison. One or two seconds is hot fire. Three to four, medium, and five to six, medium low. "There are not many meats, or seafood or poultry, that you can grill below medium-low," he says.
How to shop smartly
Whatever the price, look for signs the grill is well-made:
- Examine the grate for quality, weight and how well it fits into the grill, says Cheryl Jamison.
- Make sure the grill doesn't wobble or roll, and the cart (if there is one) is solid.
- Look for good soldering. If it's flimsy or looks like it would move around while you're using it, that's not a good sign.
- One expert's trick is to take a magnet to the store, says Connelly. "If the stainless steel has any magnetic properties to it, it means it's pretty cheap stainless, and it could start to rust," he says.
- Another good sign in a gas grill is burners that are warranted for 10 years or more.
And shop a variety of store types (warehouse, specialty retailer, home improvement) before you make your selection.
"You really need to look around and see as many options as you can," says Bill Jamison. "You should do your shopping and not run to the nearest warehouse store and buy what looks good or is the cheapest."