Dear Dr. Don,
I recently retired at age 63 with a $360,000 pension. Having raised 4 daughters, I have bad credit. Now, I’m having trouble getting a loan to buy a house. So I’m considering purchasing a home with cash, avoiding paying interest on a mortgage. Homes are relatively inexpensive here in Phoenix. I’d still have plenty of money left. And I have my Social Security benefits. What do you think?
— Jeff Jump-start
First, let’s get one thing straight: Having 4 daughters is not an elegant excuse for having bad credit. I hope you aren’t blaming them for the fix you are in. Having said that, I’m here to help! With time, you can fix your credit score. The pension decision, however, would be more permanent.
The lump-sum conundrum
I think the decision whether to take the lump-sum value of your pension is one of the most difficult decisions a retiree faces. You want to be able to meet your retirement income needs and manage the risk of outlasting your income.
Housing costs, of course, are a key income need in retirement. If you use part of your $360,000 to buy a personal residence, you’ve taken care of part of that expense. That leaves property taxes, utilities, maintenance and insurance as recurring costs. By owning the home outright, you have the ability to later take out a home equity conversion mortgage or reverse mortgage to serve as a financial backstop.
Social Security timing
You should consider avoiding taking Social Security at least until your full retirement age. If you are single, that means waiting until you’re 66 years, 9 months old.
People typically decide on taking the lump sum thinking they’ll fare better than if receiving the annuity payments being offered by the employer’s pension plan. Some need to fund a retirement expense. It appears you are in the latter camp.
The bottom line
I think you’d be better off taking the lump sum and using some of the money to buy your home. You can also use some of the money for expenses to delay taking Social Security.
Work through this decision with a fee-only financial planner to better understand your retirement income options and investment decisions, including the tax implications of any decision you make.
Get more news, money-saving tips and expert advice by signing up for a free Bankrate newsletter.
Ask the adviser
To ask a question of Dr. Don, go to the “Ask the Experts” page and select one of these topics: “Financing a home,” “Saving & Investing” or “Money.” Read more Dr. Don columns for additional personal finance advice.