The Best Car Insurance Companies in Ohio 2020

Fact-checked with

4 min read

When researching and choosing an Ohio auto insurance policy, you need to consider several factors: your budget, the amount of coverage needed, your driving record, discounts you may qualify for and more.

As of 2016, there were nearly 8 million licensed drivers in the state of Ohio. According to the Ohio State Highway Patrol, there were 555 traffic fatalities in the year 2019, as well as 322,000 enforcement stops and 32,777 crashes investigated.

Drivers in Ohio face less risk on the road compared to drivers in some other states, but you still need an Ohio auto insurance policy with good coverage at an affordable price in the event you need to file a claim.

The top car insurance companies in Ohio

The following is a list of the top Ohio auto insurance companies in the North Central region, according to J.D. Power‘s 2020 U.S. Auto Insurance Study.

Insurance Provider J.D. Power Rating
Geico 851/1,000
Erie Insurance 846/1,000
Auto-Owners 845/1,000
Westfield 836/1,000
Grange Insurance 832/1,000
Looking to save money on auto insurance?
Looking to save money on auto insurance?

Looking to save money on auto insurance?

Compare rates & save


In J.D. Power’s auto insurance study, Geico claimed the top spot for overall customer satisfaction in the North Central region. Geico is known for offering some of the lowest auto insurance premiums in the country, in addition to a wide range of discounts. When it comes to auto insurance coverage types, Geico offers the basics. But if you’re looking for standard coverage at the cheapest rate possible, check out Geico.

Erie Insurance

Erie Insurance was also rated highly by J.D. Power, ranking third on the list of 21 insurance providers. While Erie does not write coverage in every state, it does offer coverage in Ohio, giving Ohio residents access to great policy options and unique coverages. In addition, Erie offers a rate lock guarantee, diminishing deductible program and accident forgiveness. Its policies aren’t the cheapest, but the coverage is among the best.


Auto-Owners is one of the largest insurance companies in the country, and particularly in the North Central region. It’s known for its exceptional customer service, in part because the company works exclusively through agents. This can be either a pro or a con, depending on your preferences. Auto-Owners offers good car insurance coverages, including gap insurance and diminished value coverage, as well as discounts.


Westfield is a local insurance company that is headquartered in Ohio. In addition to insurance, it also offers banking services. All in all, Westfield car insurance is pretty average. It offers standard coverage, plus roadside assistance. Drivers can upgrade their policy with Wespak, which includes gap coverage, trip protection and replacement cost coverage. Westfield stands out for its customer service, so if you prefer to work with an agent for your insurance needs, look into Westfield.

Grange Insurance

Grange Insurance is another company that is local to Ohio. The company scored well in J.D. Power’s study, ranking 7th on the list of the best North Central car insurance providers. Grange Insurance offers impressive coverage, including full glass repair, pet coverage, rental car reimbursement, gap insurance, OEM coverage and identity theft coverage. Grange Insurance works primarily through agents, but you can file a claim and make payments online.

Average car insurance cost in Ohio

In the Buckeye State, drivers pay an average of $777.80 per year for car insurance, which is significantly less than the U.S. national average of $1,004.58. That makes Ohio the 39th most expensive state for car insurance.

Car insurance is pretty affordable in Ohio because the state doesn’t have too many uninsured drivers. According to the Insurance Information Institute, about 12.4% of Ohio drivers don’t have insurance. That puts Ohio at 22nd on the list of states with the most uninsured drivers.

State minimum insurance requirements in Ohio

Ohio law requires drivers to purchase Bodily Injury Liability Coverage (a minimum of $25,000 per person injured in any one accident and $50,000 for all persons injured in any one accident) as well as Property Damage Liability Coverage (a minimum of $25,000 for injury to or destruction of property of others in any one accident). Drivers also must have a certificate of proof of financial responsibility.

Finding the right cheap car insurance in Ohio for you

Car insurance rates in Ohio are highly personalized. The price you pay depends on several factors, including your zip code, your age, your credit score, your claims history, the age of your car, the value of your car and more. However, some car insurance companies are better suited for certain types of drivers.

  • Cheapest car insurance for people with low credit: If you have poor credit, go with a Geico policy. The company offers cheap premiums to all drivers, but drivers with a low credit score will benefit the most.
  • Cheapest car insurance for students: Students can save big with a policy from Auto-Owners. The company offers a discount of up to 20% for students with a cumulative “B” grade point average or better. It also offers a student away at school discount and a teen driver monitoring discount.

Car insurance discounts in Ohio

Car insurance in Ohio is already affordable, but most insurance providers offer additional ways to save money on your premium. For example, some companies reward drivers with a lower premium if they pay their policy in full, have certain safety features installed in their vehicle and maintain a clean driving record. Here are the discounts that the cheapest car insurance companies in Ohio offer.

Geico Erie Auto-Owners Westfield Grange
Multi-Policy X X X X X
Good Student X X X X
Paid-in-Full Discount X X X
Vehicle Safety Equipment X X X
Anti-Theft Equipment X X X
Good Driving History X X X X X

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest car insurance in Ohio?

Based on our evaluation, the cheapest car insurance company in Ohio is Geico. Geico offers the lowest rates for almost every driver, which is ideal for high-risk drivers and people with poor credit. Just keep in mind that Geico does not offer the greatest coverage or the best customer service.

What information is needed in order to get car insurance in Ohio?

To get Ohio auto insurance, you will need a driver’s license, your bank information, date of birth and social security number, your car’s vehicle identification number and the address of the car’s registration.

Am I legally required to have car insurance in Ohio?

Yes, if you own a car in Ohio, you must have car insurance and your coverage must include the minimum state requirements.