Dear Dr. Don,
I’m wondering whether my husband and I should refinance our home. The current mortgage is $212,000 at 3.75 percent. We would like a cash-out refinancing, using $50,000 to buy a small house in Mexico. The interest rate on the new mortgage will be at 4.75 percent. We’d pay a higher rate because of our credit scores. The bank’s appraisal of our current home is $345,000. I don’t want to sign the paperwork if this is a bad decision.
— Lucy Loans
I can’t speak directly regarding an investment in Mexican real estate, but I don’t like the idea of using a cash-out refinancing to fund the home purchase.
Instead, you should look into a home equity line of credit or home equity loan to raise the money.
The reason for this approach is twofold. First, why pay extra interest on your $212,000 first mortgage balance to borrow an additional $50,000?
The table below illustrates why you should stick with your current mortgage and use a home equity line or loan to borrow the $50,000. I’m assuming a rate of 6.15 percent for a home equity loan. The rate of 4.81 percent (recently the national average) for a home equity line of credit, or HELOC, would increase savings.
Cost of equity loan vs. cash-out refi
|Loan amount||Interest rate||First year’s interest expense|
|Existing first mortgage||$212,000||3.75%||$7,950|
|Home equity loan||$50,000||6.15%||$3,075|
|Cash-out first mortgage||$262,000||4.75%||$12,445|
|Amount saved with equity loan||$1,420|
Secondly, a new cash-out first mortgage will have much higher closing costs than a home equity line or loan. Bankrate’s recent national average for closing costs on a new first mortgage is $2,539. Closing costs on a HELOC should be minimal. The closing costs on a home equity loan should be somewhere between the cash-out refinancing and the HELOC.
A HELOC is an adjustable-rate loan, with interest-only payments during the draw period, usually the first 10 years of the loan. At the end of the draw period, the loan typically becomes an amortized loan, meaning the monthly payment is increased to a level that covers the repayment of the loan balance over the remaining loan term.
A home equity loan is a fixed-rate loan, with amortized payments over the loan term. I’d lean toward the HELOC, but I suggest you work at paying down principal during the draw period.
Get more news, money-saving tips and expert advice by signing up for a free Bankrate newsletter.
Ask the adviser
To ask a question of Dr. Don, go to the “Ask the Experts” page and select one of these topics: “Financing a home,” “Saving & Investing” or “Money.” Read more Dr. Don columns for additional personal finance advice.