Mortgage
lenders want a commitment
-- and they're willing to pay you for it
By Michael
D. Larson Bankrate.com
"Mortgage
lenders seeking stable homeowners. Suitable candidates should be
prepared to commit to their loans for as long as five years. Willing
to pay top dollar -- or at least half a percentage point in rate
-- for the business."
Sound like an attractive offer? Then maybe you
should consider a prepayment penalty mortgage, which allows borrowers
who agree not to pay off their loan balances in the first few years
to get lower interest rates. They're becoming increasingly common
in the states that permit them today as lenders look for anything
to make their loans look cheaper in the face of rising rates --
and they can make sense for many consumers.
A
matter of choice
"What it really boils down to is, the customer has to make the
choice on his own," says Don Martin, owner of the mortgage brokerage
Mayflower
Capital in Los Altos, Calif. "If he thinks with high confidence
that rates are going to go up, I would say it's logical to take
the prepay to get a lower rate."
Right now, he adds, "We do have a reasonable
number of people who are considering prepayment penalties."
That isn't surprising, given what's happened
to the cost of financing in the past 10 months. After 30-year fixed-rate
mortgages plunged below 6.5 percent last October, they've climbed
steadily at times and shot up at others, only to level off around
8 percent in recent days. People left looking for ways to shave
costs can turn to any number of solutions, but accepting a prepayment
penalty is one that doesn't require much more than a signature.
The penalties are usually available on adjustable-rate
mortgages, though they do show up on some fixed-rate products as
well, experts say. Borrowers can sign on to one-, three- and five-year
agreements. Some require only that people not refinance; others
also impose the penalty for paying off a mortgage through the sale
of a home.
The
penalty zone
Most of the time, consumers are permitted to pay down their
balances by as much as 20 percent annually without triggering a
penalty. But lenders will charge a fee equal to some percentage
of the amount of debt that exceeds that payoff allowance if a borrower
goes too far.
For example, a customer with a $100,000 loan
might be allowed to pay $20,000 off in the first year. But a $25,000
prepayment would result in some kind of assessment, according to
Kirk Park, assistant vice president at Market
Street Mortgage Corp. in Clearwater, Fla. Under one common arrangement,
the borrower would have to pay six months' interest on $5,000. At
a mortgage rate of 8 percent, that would come to $200. Somebody
who paid the whole loan off would owe six months' interest on $80,000,
or $3,200.
One other type of loan in the marketplace carries
a "3/2/1" penalty. Somebody getting one of these mortgages would
have to pay 3 percent of the loan balance in the first year, 2 percent
in the second and 1 percent in the third in the event of a prepayment.
The
no-prepay prize
So what's in this for borrowers? They can expect to pay anywhere
from one-eighth of a percentage point to one-half of a percentage
point less in rate than conventional customers. A 5/1 jumbo ARM
with no points and no prepayment penalty that went for about 7.625
percent in mid-August, for instance, would carry a rate of just
7.375 percent with a penalty, according to Martin. On mortgages
that start at higher rates, such as subprime loans and loans that
don't require people to verify income or assets, the rate bonus
can be even greater.
"You as the borrower agree to pay a prepayment
penalty," says Todd Chamberlain, executive vice president of business
development at the Columbia, Md.-based lender Columbia
National Inc. "If the loan pays off in that time frame,
for that agreeing to that penalty, you obtain as a borrower, typically
a lower rate or lower points or a combination of the two upfront."
Still, borrowers should be sure they intend
to stay put before getting a prepayment loan that charges them for
selling their homes. They should be as confident as possible rates
aren't going to drop dramatically, too, because refinancing would
carry a hefty price tag. With October's rate plunge looking like
an aberration rather than something likely to happen again soon,
experts say that looks like a pretty safe bet today. But five years
from now, nobody knows where rates will be.
Not
available in all states
One final caveat: Check out local prepayment penalty regulations
by talking to a lender in your area. Some states don't allow companies
to charge prepayment penalties at all, while others have odd restrictions.
In Illinois, for example, lenders can charge prepayment penalties
on any adjustable-rate mortgage, but not on fixed-rate loans with
rates greater than 8 percent, according to Park at Market Street.
There may be slightly different rules for banks and mortgage companies,
too, although a majority of states do permit penalties in one form
or another.
|