They're
complicated and hard to find, but
unusual mortgages can serve special needs
By Michael D. Larson Bankrate.com
A 30-year
mortgage is a 30-year mortgage, right?
Not according to some lenders. Though home loans
look more and more alike these days regardless of where you shop,
not all offerings taste like chicken. Some brokerage houses, mortgage
companies and credit unions offer loans that meet specific needs,
and experts say experienced consumers can benefit by seeking them
out.
"For people who are buying for the first time,
I don't normally recommend that," says Rick Harper, director of
housing at the Consumer Credit Counseling Service of San
Francisco. "Today, people should be looking for a 30-year fixed
and first-time homeowners have enough trouble with the process understanding
everything."
"But if you're not a first-time buyer or you
know you're only going to be in an area for three or five years
and then you're out of there . . . that's acceptable," he adds.
"They need to know about these 'creative' types of financing."
Loans that don't fit the mold come in many shapes
and sizes. Some allow a borrower to put little or even no money
down in exchange for getting more than one mortgage on the property
or paying a higher interest rate. Others allow people to pledge
a certain amount of their assets in lieu of actually cashing them
out and putting the money toward their home purchases. But all of
them go against the 1990s trend toward lending uniformity fueled
by the so-called secondary market.
"Why is there so much standardization in the
industry? There's a very simple answer for that -- Freddie
Mac and Fannie Mae,"
says Harper.
The two agencies buy loans from lenders, and
either hold them in their portfolios or package them into bonds
called mortgage-backed securities that are sold to Wall Street investors.
To protect themselves from risk inherent in the process, they set
underwriting standards that loans they buy have to meet. The process
replenishes lender funds so they can make more loans. But it also
means that a huge New York-based conglomerate and a small bank in
White River Junction, Vt., are essentially offering the same product.
A
few lenders break the mold
Against that backdrop, some companies try to compete with specialized
mortgages. One such offering comes from Fidelity
Brokerages Services Inc., a division of the Boston-based mutual
fund and financial services firm Fidelity Investments, and GMAC Mortgage Corp.,
the Horsham, Pa.-based home financing arm of General
Motors Corp.
The Fidelity Pledged Asset Program allows its
brokerage customers to use stocks, bonds or other assets as a pseudo
down payment. Instead of having to sell those assets to raise cash,
they pledge a percentage of them to the mortgage company and obtain
a loan for as much as the full value of the home.
"If a customer wants to buy a $200,000 home,
the first thing they would do is have a conversation with GMAC Mortgage
and GMAC Mortgage would help them determine what loan program is
appropriate for them," says Sara Adelizzi, vice president of Fidelity
Brokerage Services. "If they choose a pledge program, GMAC will
tell the customer about the down payment requirement -- in most
cases 20 percent to avoid mortgage insurance -- and that's $40,000."
A customer would then talk to Fidelity and find
out what percentage of assets can be borrowed against "on margin."
Margin loans allow people to borrow up to 50 percent of the value
of their portfolios to buy more shares, bonds or other financial
investments. The percentage of their overall assets they are allowed
to borrow against depends on the composition of the portfolio; someone
with all risky stocks usually would be able to borrow less than
someone with a lot of conservative bonds or mutual funds.
Taking
the pledge
Traditional margin agreements require customers to pay interest
on the money loaned, but pledged asset borrowers don't. Someone
with an $80,000 portfolio could therefore pledge $40,000 to Fidelity,
get a $200,000 mortgage from GMAC and pay only for the added principal
and interest costs of borrowing the larger amount rather than $160,000.
Because investments in the portfolio would have more time to appreciate
and borrowers wouldn't have to pay capital gains taxes usually attached
to asset liquidations, a borrower could make out well in the transaction.
"As long as the customer has more than $40,000
available to borrow, they're good to go with this loan," Adelizzi
says.
Still, there's no guarantee the value of the
portfolio backing the loan will rise. A borrower could end up getting
a margin call, or request from Fidelity to deposit more cash or
stock into the account to keep the pledged amount from exceeding
the available borrowing limit. Otherwise, Fidelity would be authorized
to get the money through harsher means.
If the $80,000 portfolio dropped to $30,000
in value because of a severe market drop, for instance, Fidelity
could liquidate the securities in the account and the borrower would
still owe the company $10,000. That wouldn't automatically jeopardize
the customer's home because GMAC wouldn't modify the loan or try
to foreclose as long as the person kept making payments. But it
would mean he'd owe money on more than just the mortgage, increasing
the chances of default.
Borrowers who want to avoid market risk but
like the idea of pledging money rather than handing it over can
find other such loans. At Boeing Employees' Credit Union, members
can obtain up to 100 percent financing through a certificate of
deposit-based program.
A typical scenario might work like this: Customer
A has $3,000 available to buy a $100,000 home. That's only enough
to cover closing costs, however, so he needs some help. Under the
mortgage guidelines, his $3,000 could fill the required 3 percent
"investment" in the property while a $5,000 pledged CD from a family
member could take the place of a traditional down payment. The borrower
gets a home and the relative earns interest off the CD. Meanwhile,
the lender is protected in the event of a default.
"The idea behind the pledged asset, I guess,
is it's a way most likely for parents to help their kids get into
a home without giving up their savings," says Mark Jones, secondary
marketing manager at BECU in Tukwila, Wash. "The choice for the
parent is to either give their children the $5,000 or, in this case,
keep the $5,000 here at the institution."
Other creative loan programs target borrowers
who travel and those who need extra help making payments.
A
traveler-friendly loan
Tower
Federal Credit Union of Laurel, Md. offers what it calls a "Future
Primary Residence Loan" because many of its members have civilian
or military jobs with the Department of Defense. Those workers often
take assignments abroad or in other states for a few years at a
time, but want to maintain houses they consider to be their permanent
residences in the Baltimore-Washington area that will either remain
empty or be rented.
Normally, lenders have to treat such mortgages
as investor or non owner-occupied mortgages, making them subject
to tougher underwriting guidelines. But Tower Federal charges just
one-eighth to one-quarter of a percentage point more in rate for
its 30-year fixed FPRL mortgages than it does for the conventional
equivalent. The credit union is able to do so because it doesn't
sell the loans to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
"This one really came from the mobility of some
of our members who want to stay in the area" by maintaining both
temporary and permanent homes, says Phil Porterfield, the credit
union's lending manager. "You end up with two mortgages that way,
but basically, they're paying the same market rate and that is unique."
Borrowers don't have to be credit union members
or investors to find other types of special mortgages. Crestar
Mortgage Corp., a division of SunTrust
Banks Inc. that makes loans around the country through its branches
and brokers, offers a pair of programs that cater to people who
want to avoid getting jumbo
loans or reap added tax benefits from borrowing.
The company's "Premier 100" loan resembles an
80/10/10 mortgage, but allows somebody to finance the entire purchase
price of a home. Unlike its more common sibling, which requires
a customer to get an 80 percent loan-to-value (LTV) first mortgage,
a 10 percent LTV home equity loan and put 10 percent down in cash,
this program leaves them with a 70 percent first mortgage and a
30 percent second mortgage. The rates on both the first and second
mortgages are higher with the 70/30s, but the loans can help people
with little down payment money get into homes. By keeping the first
mortgage below 80 percent LTV, they also eliminate the need for
private mortgage insurance.
An
alternative to PMI
"First of all, there has in the past been some negative press, I
guess, on MI -- mortgage insurance. This gives the borrower the
opportunity to avoid mortgage insurance," says Sue Huber, Crestar's
senior vice president of secondary marketing.
"Another reason is that if the borrower were
to take a conforming first mortgage up to $240,000 and then a second
mortgage going higher than that, he wouldn't have to pay jumbo pricing
on that. He could just pay the conforming price."
People with a little more money can play with
the numbers to get a more favorable deal too. Somebody who puts
at least 5 percent down, for example, can get an 80/15/5 loan at
much better rates than the Premier 100 offers.
"A lot of times we see a borrower who is the
type of person who gets a bonus check or some type of lump sum compensation,"
Huber says. "They might end up paying off the second mortgage and
just end up with a first mortgage at a better rate."
Borrowers who want to maximize their mortgage
interest tax deductions can choose Crestar's "Baseline 150" product
instead. The 30-year adjustable rate mortgage, whose payment fluctuates
annually based on how rates have changed, allows a borrower to make
interest-only payments the first 10 years. The option can give a
consumer a larger tax deduction. Because the mortgage has a low
5 percent lifetime adjustment cap, a borrower who got the 5.75 percent,
no-points rate available on May 27 would never pay interest at a
rate higher than 10.75.
Few
get creative with loans
Still, consumer advocates say many of these creative loans require
a thorough understanding of financing terms and definitions. They
aren't for the faint of heart, and many borrowers may end up sticking
to the basics. Jones of BECU, for one, says he's done only a half-dozen
or so of the CD pledged-asset loans since late 1996, when the program
became available.
But those with a little know-how can find sweet
deals -- if they're willing to spend some extra time searching.
"Looking at some of these really creative vehicles
for financing might assist them in their cash flow and there might
turn out to be a good program for them," says Harper of CCCS. "The
advantage of owning a home, even if it might necessitate a little
bit of a risk," makes these programs worth reviewing.
Coming
June 10
As part of our five-part theme week on money
and marriage, we explore how successful couples achieve their major
life goals, from buying a house to retiring at 50.
|