|
Monday,
Aug. 25
Posted
2 p.m. EDT
RISING:
Mortgage rates went up about
an eighth of a percentage point
Friday. Looking at mortgage
bond prices, it appears that
rates might be down a little
today, but not much.
WIDENING:
In the mortgage and bond world,
there's a concept known as "spread."
A spread is the difference between
two interest rates or bond yields.
One that I pay attention to
is the spread between the 30-year
fixed and the 10-year Treasury.
That spread has widened considerably.
To show what I
mean, let's take a look at last
week and the same week in the
previous two years. Going from
oldest to most recent:
On Aug. 23, 2006,
the 30-year fixed averaged 6.48
percent in Bankrate's weekly
survey, and the 10-year Treasury
note yielded 4.83 percent.
On Aug. 22, 2007,
the 30-year fixed averaged 6.58
percent and the 10-year Treasury
yielded 4.63 percent.
Last week, the
30-year fixed averaged 6.66
percent and the 10-year Treasury
yielded 3.79 percent.
The 10-year Treasury
yield kept going down, and the
mortgage rate kept going up.
In 2006, the difference, or
spread, was 1.65 percentage
points. A year later, it was
1.95 percentage points, and
last week it was 2.87.
Why is this happening,
and what will reverse it? I
plan to tackle those questions
in an article this week. The
short answer to the first question
is that investors are leery
of mortgage debt. A few years
ago, everyone on Wall Street
was trying to make money. Now
they're trying to keep money.
If you want to keep money, you
buy risk-free instruments such
as U.S. Treasury notes, which
are low-interest loans to the
federal government. You won't
make much money, but the government
won't default on the note.
If you want to
make more money, you invest
in mortgage-backed securities.
These instruments have a higher
yield because they come with
the risk that mortgage borrowers
will default on their home debts.
If fewer people send in their
monthly payments, mortgage-backed
securities are less valuable.
All over the world,
investors prefer to buy safe
Treasuries over less-safe mortgage-backed
securities. To entice investors,
the yields on mortgage-backed
securities must rise. And that
causes mortgage rates to rise
when compared to Treasury yields.
Another thing
is happening, too. Fannie Mae
and Freddie Mac, which guarantee
mortgages, have been adding
fees to mortgages this year.
Fannie calls them loan level
price adjustments and Freddie
calls them post-settlement delivery
fees. These fees vary, depending
on the loan-to-value ratio,
credit score and location of
the home. They can add a quarter
of a percentage point to the
rate that you pay, or more.
Thursday,
Aug. 21
Posted
4 p.m. EDT
DON'T
GET YOUR HOPES UP:
The FDIC's chairman, Sheila
Bair, has said all year that
mortgage servicers need to do
more to help homeowners who
have fallen behind on their
monthly payments. Now that the
FDIC controls IndyMac, an institution
that used to be one of the country's
biggest mortgage lenders, she
has her chance to show other
mortgage servicers how it's
done.
IndyMac
specialized in Alt-A mortgages,
which were designed for
people who wanted to lie
about their incomes so
they could qualify for
home loans. When the FDIC
shut down IndyMac Bank
in late July and reopened
it as IndyMac Federal
Bank, the bank serviced
tens of thousands of mortgages.
Over the next few months,
the FDIC-controlled IndyMac
will mail packets to about
25,000 borrowers who are
late on their IndyMac-serviced
mortgages.
Before I
describe what will be
in these packets, let
me stress that we're talking
only about homeowners
who have mortgages serviced
by IndyMac. Hundreds of
thousands of people got
mortgages from IndyMac,
and then their loans were
sold, and are being serviced
by other companies. Those
borrowers aren't going
to receive these packets
from the FDIC. If you're
supposed to send your
monthly house payment
to IndyMac, the FDIC offer
applies to you. If you're
supposed to send your
check elsewhere, the FDIC
offer doesn't apply to
you.
I await
the deluge of e-mails
from people asking, "But
what if I got my loan
from IndyMac but they
sold it?" Grrrr!
People who
are late on their IndyMac-serviced
loans will get a packet
in the mail. The packet
will contain a loan modification
contract. Here's what
the FDIC says about
these contracts:
Under
the IndyMac Federal program,
eligible mortgages would
be modified into sustainable
mortgages permanently
capped at the current
Freddie Mac survey rate
for conforming mortgages
(now about 6.5%). Modifications
would be designed to achieve
sustainable payments at
a 38 percent debt-to-income
(DTI) ratio of principal,
interest, taxes and insurance.
To reach this metric for
affordable payments, modifications
could adopt a combination
of interest rate reductions,
extended amortization,
and principal forbearance.
Note that
the FDIC plans to draw
up this modification agreement
based on a debt-to-income
ratio. That's all well
and good, but most of
these borrowers exaggerated
their incomes. It would
be safe to say that they've
fallen behind on their
payments because they
lied about their incomes.
Note also
that the FDIC isn't asking
for documentation of income
before coming up with
a loan-modification plan.
The FDIC is drawing up
loan-mod offers based
upon the incomes stated
in the loan applications.
It is mailing these flawed
offers to borrowers --
and asking borrowers to
document their incomes
when they return their
signed loan-mod docs.
I hope I'm
not being too repetitive
when I note that most
of these late payers lied
about their incomes. The
FDIC will discover this
when it gets the paperwork
back from borrowers and
sees the income documentation.
In cases where borrowers
greatly exaggerated their
incomes when they applied
for loans, the loan modifications
won't work. Not initially.
The FDIC will have to
send back modified modifications
in some cases. In many
cases, it will be clear
that the borrowers can't
afford their homes no
matter what, and no modifications
will be forthcoming.
In the normal
order of things, the mortgage
servicer asks to see income
verification first, and
then it comes up with
an offer for a loan modification,
based on the borrower's
income. The process sometimes
takes weeks or months,
and people get frustrated
as they wait by the phone
and the mailbox. The FDIC's
method -- make a modification
offer first, then verify
income -- will appear
faster. In the end, doing
the process this way might
bog things down.
No one says
it as well as uberblogger
Tanta at Calculated Risk,
who
writes:
Does this
mean that the FDIC risks
wasting a bunch of time
and energy drawing up
modification agreements
that it will be unable
to accept because when
it finally sees those
income docs, it realizes
that the borrowers still
don't qualify? Well, yeah.
But the borrowers won't
be made to wait weeks
and weeks for a mod offer,
unlike with those lousy
private mortgage servicers.
The actual ratio of successfully
executed mods might be
more or less the same,
but nobody had to spend
three weeks listening
to hold music.
|