Retirement Blog

Finance Blogs » Retirement Blog » Fix the debt or leave the country

Fix the debt or leave the country

By Barbara Whelehan ·
Friday, February 8, 2013
Posted: 6 pm ET

On Wednesday in Washington, D.C., a group of 200 people staged a protest outside the Hyatt Regency, the venue of a meeting hosted by the Campaign to Fix the Debt. The meeting's aim was to "open dialogue on the best path forward on America's growing debt problems," according to a press release from the Fix the Debt organization.

So why would a group of protestors object to such a noble cause? Most people would like to fix the debt. I know I certainly would. These protestors carried placards saying, "Fix the Greed. Save Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security."

Fix the greed?

The protestors, members of various organizations such as Center for Media and Democracy, Our DC and the AFL-CIO, call the Campaign to Fix the Debt a "corporate front group" which is planning to "gut Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid while preserving their own corporate tax loopholes." Indeed, more than 90 CEOs are members of the Fix the Debt campaign's Fiscal Leadership Council. Some of these CEOs also serve on the Business Roundtable, which recently announced fixes to the entitlement programs such as raising the Social Security retirement age to 70 and the Medicare eligibility age to 70.

The protestors find it repugnant that corporate CEOs are involved in these efforts to fix the debt by tampering with social programs. "There has to be a refocusing of the discussion on corporate welfare and corporate tax loopholes before we can begin having a discussion about cutting the social safety net," says James Adams, a spokesperson for Our DC, a nonprofit whose mission is to bring good jobs to the District of Columbia. "America ain't broke. It's just that many of these corporations aren't paying their fair share."

Phone calls and emails to Campaign to Fix the Debt were not returned. I looked at the website, and couldn't find any concrete solutions to fix the debt. But among the organization's core principles is to "reform Medicare and Medicaid," and "strengthen Social Security." The plan to fix the debt should "include comprehensive and pro-growth tax reform, which broadens the base, lowers rates, raises revenues and reduces the deficit."

Lowering tax rates and raising revenues seem to be at odds. I asked my colleague Kay Bell about the paradox, and she replied: "Deficit hawks love to use the personal budget analogy: 'When you, meaning average American families, have to deal with your budgets, you know that some expenses have to go.'"

But folks in lower tax rates find their budgets are already squeezed. Adams of Our DC says the protesters at Wednesday's summit notice when a medication increases $5 or when there's a decrease in reimbursements. "They look at the $23 million salary that the CEO of Verizon is making and say, 'Come on, who can bear the brunt of this?'"

"Meanwhile, the high earners," says Kay Bell, "don't usually pinpoint which tax breaks they would be willing to forgo."

Wealth flight

Higher tax rates is a touchy subject, especially among the wealthy. This is true even though our highest tax rates are among the lowest that the richest taxpayers have had to pay over the past century. The table below shows that the highest tax rates are near their lows relative to earlier decades.

The other day I received notification that an increasing number of America's wealthy individuals are thinking about moving abroad to escape taxation here. "When high-net-worth individuals are taxed to perceived excessive levels, they simply move to lower tax jurisdictions -- because they have the resources to do so," according to Nigel Green, CEO of the deVere Group, an international financial advisory firm with offices in roughly three dozen countries that cater to expatriates.

Where are the tax-haven hot spots, I asked? "If they give up their passports -- as an increasing number are doing, official figures show -- then it would be anywhere with tax less than 30 percent: The Cayman Islands, Hong Kong, Thailand, Malaysia and the Philippines are amongst the popular destinations," was the reply.

What do you think about Americans who make their money here and then renounce their citizenship and leave the country to avoid paying taxes here?


Follow me on Twitter @BWhelehan.

Barbara Whelehan is a co-author of "Future Millionaires' Guidebook," an e-book written by Bankrate editors and reporters. It is available at Amazon, Barnes & Noble, iBookstore and other e-book retailers.

Bankrate wants to hear from you and encourages comments. We ask that you stay on topic, respect other people's opinions, and avoid profanity, offensive statements, and illegal content. Please keep in mind that we reserve the right to (but are not obligated to) edit or delete your comments. Please avoid posting private or confidential information, and also keep in mind that anything you post may be disclosed, published, transmitted or reused.

By submitting a post, you agree to be bound by Bankrate's terms of use. Please refer to Bankrate's privacy policy for more information regarding Bankrate's privacy practices.
February 16, 2013 at 6:10 pm

Fix or Leave? Well, it's a free country, so if you want to go, go. No one will miss you. But whether you think our taxes are too high or too low, you don't get much better living conditions than right here in the USA. The deficit can be fixed, but how do you trust Congress to do it when they got us into this mess in the first place. They are so beholden to special interest groups and corporations, they can't see what's best for the American people and do the right thing. As much as some people would like to believe, this is not about being a republican or democrat. They have all sold us out. They have all dipped into our Social Security fund. They have all let Medicare get out of control, without fixing (lowering costs) some of it's basic problems. Many scream at the thought of reducing (or at least curtailing growth) the military budget. They try to tell people we won't be safe if we don't increase the military budget by billions each year. There's probably enough fat in the military budget to last for decades (any one here old enough to remember the Pentagon Procurement scandal years ago, when it was discovered they were paying $600 for replacement toilet seats and $100 for wrenches, all hardware items you could buy for $5?). Everything needs to be on the table. No sacred cows. But you can't just take an axe to the budget numbers. Programs can be fixed, thus saving billions. The problem is, Congress just doesn't know how to fix anything. They just argue about the numbers.

February 13, 2013 at 3:04 pm

It's not only the rich wanting to make their money and leave! Living here in the DC Metro area, I have come across the same mindset; but from the other end of the spectrum. Example: once a friend and I hailed a taxi. Long story, short, my friend asked the driver if he loved this country and wanted to become a citizen - the reply was "No - I'm just here to make money"..(my friend)"Do you pay taxes?" (taxi driver)"h@*l no!".

Our poor country has been abused and misused in more ways than one - very sad!!

February 09, 2013 at 11:19 am

What do you think about Americans who make their money here and then renounce their citizenship and leave the country to avoid paying taxes here?


What do you think of a government that demonizes these people and forcibly takes more of their EARNINGS?

You cannot just focus on the federal tax rates while ignoring all the other taxes imposed, like Corporate taxes (aren't those the highest in the world?), state income tax like CA's 13.3%, Obamacare taxes and fees etc...., unless you have a leftwing agenda.