If you've ever purchased life insurance, you've probably had that fleeting thought cross your mind: What if they don't pay up? After all, it's not like you'll be in any position to do much about it.
Well, it seems that life insurers sometimes don't pay up. And now a lynch mob of state attorneys general wants to know why.
The mob formed three years ago around Verus Financial, a Connecticut auditing firm that offered to help states ferret out instances where some of the nation's largest insurers welshed on deceased policyholders. The states could then seize the unclaimed life payouts as abandoned property, thereby potentially returning millions to their cash-strapped coffers.
Some 35 states signed on, agreeing to give Verus Financial a piece of the action, according to the Wall Street Journal. But the movement has grown and tempers have flared as inspectors peered beneath the veneer of good old life insurance to see the creaky, and perhaps deceitful, practices that lurk beneath.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners launched its own task force to help sleuth out what it estimates to be more than $1 billion in unpaid death benefits on thousands of small policies, many written in the 1940s and '50s.
The latest flare-up came last week when New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman subpoenaed a veritable Who's Who of American life insurance companies to explore whether insurers do enough to determine when a policyholder has died and benefits are due.
Bloomberg, quoting an anonymous source, listed the subpoenaed companies as AXA Equitable, Genworth, Guardian, John Hancock, MassMutual, MetLife, New York Life, Prudential and TIAA-CREF.
At issue is whether the insurers: a) use the proper databases to determine if a policyholder has died and/or b) conveniently cherry-pick the data to avoid paying benefits to the surviving families.
Regulators say they should be using the Social Security Administration's Death Master File, just as they do to cancel annuity contracts. The life insurance companies insist they have done nothing illegal, and that they are under no contractual obligation to determine if their policyholders are still alive.
There have been a few settlements. A few insurers have agreed to use the Death Master List. But there's still a stench about the whole story that just doesn't play well in Peoria.
If you have elderly friends or family members, you know how easily things like brokerage accounts, bank accounts and insurance policies can be misplaced or forgotten.
Life insurance companies may not have a fiduciary duty -- yet -- to uphold their end of these contracts.
But I would submit that they have a moral one.
Follow me on Twitter.
Subscribe to Bankrate newsletters today!