Market timing: Smart or a fool's game?

One of the most frequently cited admonitions to individual investors is, "Don't try to time financial markets."

To time the market means trying to buy assets in it near the end of a slump and to sell them near the end of a rally, rather than just buying and holding. This strategy enables investors to buy low and sell high, as well as preserve their capital. The problem: It's tough to know which direction the market is headed.

Still, many investment experts say market timing is a useful tool. "The investment environment since 2000 has seen dramatic ups and downs, which certainly has created the argument that market timing or more aggressive asset allocation should be incorporated into investors' portfolios," says Michael Sheldon, chief market strategist at RDM Financial Group in Westport, Conn.

Chris Litchfield, a former hedge fund manager and now a private investor in Greenwich, Conn., puts it in even stronger terms. "People say (market timing) isn't for individuals, but being fully invested is insanity," he says. "We're in a period after a secular bull market for stocks where they go nowhere for about 20 years. Blindly buying and holding is a disaster."

But keep in mind that market timing isn't an easy endeavor. "The problem is you have to be able to get in and out at the right time," Sheldon says. "Not many investors are able to do that successfully over a long period of time."

Tweaking your portfolio

To many investors, market timing means tweaking your portfolio allocations a bit, increasing exposure to an asset that has fallen in price and decreasing one that has risen.

"When we believe risk is rising, we slowly take money off the table," says Tim Ghriskey, chief investment officer at Solaris Asset Management in Bedford Hills, N.Y. "We don't day trade the entire portfolio, but we move in the direction of raising cash when we think the risk is rising."

Dick Dickson, senior market strategist at Lowry Research in Palm Beach Gardens, Fla., sees it differently. He advocates going all in to a market or all out. That's how you avoid big moves lower and catch big moves higher, he says.

If you're going to try market timing, how do you go about doing it? A simple and more subtle way than going all in or out is to rebalance your portfolio after major market moves, similar to what Ghriskey describes.

Mick Heyman, an independent financial adviser in San Diego, recommends staying close to whatever asset allocation you have set for your portfolio. "If you decide on a portfolio of 60 percent stocks, stay between 50 (percent) and 70 percent. Sometimes people go to 75 percent or more, and I don't think that's wise."

At this point, with bond yields so low and stock dividends so high, Heyman would be reluctant to lighten up on stocks. But if stocks -- particularly dividend stocks -- gain another 10 percent to 20 percent and interest rates rise significantly, that would be an argument to shift to bonds, he says.


          Connect with us

Learn the latest trends that will help grow your portfolio, plus tips on investing strategies. Delivered weekly.

CDs and Investment

Need to invest $3K for the long term?

Dear Dr. Don, What's the best place to invest $3,000 for the long term? I'm interested in earning the best rates with low or no fees. Thanks, -- Cheryl Compounds Dear Cheryl, You've got (at least) three questions to... Read more



Dr Don Taylor

Frugal living to build wealth?

What I'm not sure if we should admire Read for the size of his estate or feel sorry for him because he didn't use his wealth during his lifetime for life goals.  ... Read more

Partner Center

Connect with us