3 ways to lose a HELOC, keep the house

Justin Harelikq_v2.gifDear Bankruptcy Adviser,
I have a line of credit secured by my home (a home equity line of credit, or a second mortgage). We have a first mortgage as well. ... If I declare Chapter 7 bankruptcy, will the line of credit (like a credit card with no more credit available) be dismissed through a bankruptcy? Thank you for your help.
-- Vicki

a_v2.gifDear Vicki,
I am asked this question every single day. I always understand where the question is coming from -- a position of desperation. You are desperate to keep your home, but you cannot afford to make payments on the line of credit.

The first answer is "no" you cannot eliminate a home equity line of credit, or HELOC, that is secured by your home in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy while keeping the house. That line of credit must be paid in order to keep your property.

There are three other solutions, one that is inside bankruptcy and two outside.

3 ways to lose a HELOC but keep the house:
  1. File for Chapter 13 bankruptcy.
  2. Settle with the lender holding the credit line.
  3. Modify the line-of-credit payment.

1. Chapter 13 bankruptcy

Like many people today, you might not have any equity in your house. In fact, you might be so far upside down that the value of your house is worth less than what you owe on your first mortgage. For example, you owe $250,000 on the first mortgage, but the current fair market value of your property is only $200,000.

In a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, known as a reorganization bankruptcy, you could have the HELOC, or second mortgage, eliminated -- wiped out -- after you complete your case. The catch is a Chapter 13 bankruptcy lasts at least three years and could take as long as five years. The time period will depend on your income.

In that reorganization period, you will make payments to your first mortgage lender as well as to the court, or more specifically the trustee assigned to your case. After the period is over, you will eliminate the line of credit and any credit card balances. These lenders might get paid something over the bankruptcy period. However, any remaining balance will be eliminated once you complete the bankruptcy.

2. Settle with the lender holding the line of credit

Recently, quite a few clients have told me that the second mortgage lender has given them a one-time, lump-sum settlement offer. This means the HELOC lender understands there is no equity in the property and that, if it foreclosed, that lender would get paid nothing.

This could be a viable option. Even so, you likely will find it difficult to pay the settlement in one payment. You could borrow money from friends or family, but that's risky because it could end your relationship if you fail to pay the money back. Or, you could take the money from a retirement account. If you take this option, you could have tax consequences from the early withdraw.

3. Modify the line-of-credit payment

If you are upside down on the property, you could negotiate a modification with the lender. The line-of-credit lender would rather receive something than be forced to write off another loan. You may be in a position to tell the lender that you can afford only so much. If the HELOC lender does not want that payment, you may be unable to afford the house. Be sure that's the case before drawing a line in the sand with the lender.

The options are not great, but a few do exist. You must make an objective decision and not base your decision on emotion. You will need to be diligent and persistent if you decide on options No. 2 or No. 3. You might only get one opportunity to work out something with the lender.

To ask a question of the Bankruptcy Adviser go to the "Ask the Experts" page, and select "Bankruptcy" as the topic. Read more Bankruptcy Adviser columns and more stories about debt management.

News alert Create a news alert for "debt"


Show Bankrate's community sharing policy
          Connect with us
Credit cards on a table

Get advice for managing credit cards, building your credit history and improving your credit score. Delivered weekly.

Debt Adviser

Is power of attorney status risky?

Dear Debt Adviser, I am so glad you recently posted a question about an elderly mother. My mother has dementia. Eight years ago, she opened a credit card for a family member who has now declared bankruptcy. My mom only... Read more

Partner Center

Connect with us