Home equity line can
be
good source of tuition money
By Michael
D. Larson Bankrate.com
The college application? No problem.
The drive to school? Piece of cake.
Now, though, it's time to pay up.
And if savings or other assets aren't an option, a home equity line
of credit can be a good tool despite several pitfalls, experts say.
"A lot of people really don't qualify for a
lot of financial aid because their incomes are so high but, nevertheless,
they haven't put a lot of money aside for college," says Michael
Ryan, a certified financial planner with Professional Planning Group
in Westerly, R.I. "They're left with just having to borrow the money
on their own, and the line of credit is a pretty convenient and
tax-advantaged way to do that."
Well-suited home equity
lines
The benefits of using the same house a student was raised in to
pay for their college education stem from several rate and cost
characteristics of home equity lines of credit. They are less expensive
than personal loans, for example, and aren't subject to the income
limits that bar some families from obtaining government-backed loans.
Most usually have tax-deductible interest as well, because they
use a borrower's home for collateral like a regular mortgage.
Another advantage: The lines are more flexible
than home equity loans, or second mortgages. That's because people
can take out the amount of money they need when they need it, making
them ideal for families with kids who are heading off to college
at staggered times.
"You could draw it down, then pay it back, and
draw it down again," said Joe Anderson, vice president of consumer
lending at Baltimore-based Provident Bankshares Corp.
Reasonable
costs
Rates are very competitive, too, when compared to unsecured personal
loans and even home equity loans. In the latest Bankrate.com national
survey, for instance, the average line of credit rate was 6.98 percent,
compared with 9.02 percent for a home loan and 14.88 percent for
a personal one. The interest rates on home equity lines of credit
float during the life of the loan, however, while other types of
loans establish fixed payments.
Finally, lenders often eat closing costs for
borrowers who activate their lines right away by putting a balance
on them, or for people with high credit limits.
Be
careful to protect retirement
Still, borrowers can get into trouble easily when using the lines
of credit because college comes at a crucial time for most parents.
Ryan notes that people using them to pay for
a child's education generally aren't too far from retiring. By putting
more debt on their homes, they will reduce or eliminate its accumulated
equity -- potentially wiping out a prime source of "golden
years" income, since retirees tend to sell big properties to move
into smaller, cheaper homes.
"It's a seemingly painless way to pay for college
education, but I think the real problem won't become apparent until
10 or 20 years down the road when retirement is looming," says Ryan.
"You're starting all over again with those mortgage payments, so
you're right back to square one."
Look
at other sources
If families can get by with small infusions of cash,
they might want to talk to their hometown banker.
Citizens State Bank of Loyal, Wis., tries to
steer its regular customers toward a discounted personal loan in
the names of both the parents and the student, according to vice
president Rick Szymanski. The loans are typically for no more than
$2,000 -- covering only part of the college costs -- but they carry
rates of just 10 percent or so, he says. They can also be structured
so customers pay only interest while their children are in school.
Planners also say families who qualify for
government loans should take them rather than using any home equity.
"Your interest rate is clearly better than you'd
get doing a home equity line," says Patti Houlihan, a certified
financial planner at Cavill and Company in Oakton, Va. The first
payments also won't be due until six or nine months after the student
finishes classes.
Parents in such a situation can choose from
Perkins,
Stafford and PLUS loans, each of which have different terms,
conditions and borrowing limits. Perkins rates are generally the
lowest at a fixed 5 percent, while the other two, which are tied
to the movements of different Treasury bills, are currently a bit
higher.
As a final caution, planners also suggest students
contribute some of their own income from a job or other source to
their education because it will give them a financial stake in the
matter.
-- Updated: July 20, 2001
|