Life insurance for kids?
you want to start an argument, ask a group of financial advisers what they think
about buying life insurance for children.
To some, it's a great, low-cost way to set money aside for the
future and to make sure he'll have insurance as an adult, in case an illness
later in life makes him uninsurable. Others say it's an outdated product that
has been replaced by more effective savings tools, such as 529 plans. Still
others say that since the purpose of insurance is to replace a wage-earner's
income, it's inherently wrong to sell insurance on someone who doesn't have
According to research from the American Council of Life Insurers,
life insurance for children isn't a popular purchase. They report that only
about 15 percent of people under the age of 18 have life insurance, a percentage
that has stayed steady for more than a decade. The average amount of coverage
on children is small, usually in the range of $5,000. Many companies will tack
on a small amount of insurance to a parent's policy, essentially to cover burial
Still, it's a commonly asked question and many parents aren't
sure what to do, if anything.
"Most folks are torn," says Victor Gainor, second vice
president of individual insurance products for TIAA-CREF, a life insurance company
for teachers and their families.
He bought modest whole-life insurance policies for both of his
children, along with opening 529 plans and setting up mutual funds. He did it
primarily, he says, as a way to make sure that they'll always have some insurance
and to have some cash available if his family gets in a jam.
"I didn't buy it to make money; I bought it to give to them
while I have my other bases covered," he says. "I can also access
the cash values that are accruing and use it for tuition or whatever I need
to do for my family."
There's even disagreement about the kind of insurance that should
available for children. TIAA-CREF won't sell term insurance on children, saying
it "flies in the face" of the mission of the organization because
it doesn't provide the policyholder with a way to accrue cash value.
John Sestina, a fee-only certified financial planner in Columbus,
Ohio, and the author of Managing
to be Wealthy, says the only kind of insurance he would recommend buying
for children is term insurance -- and if you're going to get it, get lots.
Sestina sees other investments, such as Roth IRAs, as making
more sense for building wealth for kids.
The future insurability issue
The only reason he can see for buying life insurance for children is if there's
a family history of health problems, such as diabetes or heart disease, that
might make it tough for them to get insurance when they're in their prime income-earning
"If your child has the potential for health problems, you'll
have to buy a ton -- at least a million dollars," he says.
Since it's impossible to determine how much a child will make
in the future, Sestina recommends using your own income as a guideline. The
cheapest deal, he says, is on a 20-year policy. Try to get one that is renewable
and has the option of converting to whole life insurance.
Since many insurance companies don't sell high-quality term insurance
for children, Sestina recommends having an independent agent find a good policy
Dave Christopher is vice president of risk product management
for Thrivent Financial for Lutherans, a fraternal benefits society that uses
life insurance and other investments to support the Lutheran denomination.
Many of his members buy cash-value policies for their children
because of the insurability issue. A $10,000 policy bought for a child can be
increased to $280,000 worth of coverage as an adult without medical testing.
Thrivent also markets the policies as a way to invest money on
a tax-deferred basis. Since it's the gains on the investment that are taxed,
the first withdrawals are from the premiums, which are tax-free.
"If you've accessed all the premium, you can take out loans
against the gains on a tax-free basis as well," he says.
The catch is that you have to keep the policy until you die, or
you do pay taxes on what you take out.
Bard Malovany, a certified financial planner in Annandale, Va.,
gets particularly steamed with agents who use guilt as a sales technique.
"I've heard people sell life insurance by saying, 'Don't
you love your children?' The answer is 'Yes, but that's not relative (to the
Malovany says he doesn't buy the argument of buying whole life
insurance policies for children as an investment to save for the future. They're
"not that great of an investment," he says, and there are better options
available, such as 529 plans and Education IRAs, that don't include a life insurance
"If it's not a great investment option and you don't need
the risk protection," he says, "what's the point? Some people just
feel better having it. They say, 'If my kid passes away, I'll be grieving. Having
$100,000 wouldn't hurt.'"
Life insurance child abuse?
Bob MacDonald is chairman of the board of Minneapolis-based Allianz Life of
North America, and has worked in the insurance industry for 40 years. He thinks
selling life insurance for children is as contemptible as tobacco companies
advertising cigarettes to children.
"I've always felt purchasing life insurance on children was
an inappropriate waste," he says. "There's no reason for it, unless
the child is going to star in 'Home Alone 5.' Beyond that, it's an abuse."
He feels there are better ways to save money for college, the
cost of a funeral isn't that onerous and the chance of a child becoming uninsurable
as an adult is extremely small.
"Most people are insurable until they're 80 nowadays,"
he says. "The number of people in their 20s who are uninsurable is infinitesimally
The worst sin, he says, is convincing parents to buy insurance
on their children when they're underinsured themselves. On that topic, the financial
experts are agreed. Parents have no business even thinking about life insurance
for their kids until their own needs are completely covered.
MacDonald says that if parents want to do something for college,
fine, but "it's much more appropriate to put it into vehicles that will
benefit (the children) while they're living because the chances are very good
that they will. If you take and put the same amount of money into a mutual fund
or an annuity, you would have ended up with more money in cash than you would
have had as a face amount of a policy. You are paying mortality charges and
fees that are simply not necessary for a child."
So what's a parent to do? Take a page from what you tell your
kids. Don't make a decision just because it's what everybody else is doing --
or isn't doing. Look at all the choices, and do what makes the most sense for
Pat Curry is a contributing editor based
-- Posted: Sept. 23, 2003