Disputing purchases on your credit card
The credit card is arguably the most useful of all modern conveniences.
It saves you from carrying large bundles of cash and, in most cases,
that slice of plastic is universal currency.
Credit-card companies, the financial institutions that issue them
and the merchants that honour them have established an intricate
system designed to make paying with plastic expedient and ostensibly
But there will come a time in every card holder's consumer travels
when she will question a credit-card transaction, either because
the item purchased is defective or somehow undesirable, or because
she has no recollection of having made that purchase.
Reversing a credit-card transaction is by no means impossible,
but it can be arduous and protracted, simply because of all of the
parties involved in the processing end. It helps to understand what
goes on behind the scenes.
How the credit card system works
When you hand a sales clerk your card, he must
first authorize it. Scanning your number into his computer, he dials
up the store's bank, which sends a request to the financial institution
that issued your card to ensure your card is valid and has sufficient
funds. The process takes a matter of seconds.
At the end of a business day, the merchant delivers all of his
sales draft information to his own bank, which is how the merchant
obtains his funds from the various credit-card purchases made at
the store. The merchant's bank creates an electronic version of
the drafts, which are forwarded to the credit card's data centre.
The data centre then files these drafts to the banks that issued
each consumer their credit card (making sure to include all fees,
currency conversions, etc). The issuing bank receives the file and
posts the transactions to the card holder's account. That same bank
then dispatches the owing funds to a settlement bank, which is responsible
for delivering the funds to the bank that supports the merchant.
There are no regulations in Canada that oversee this transaction
flow. Card companies and participating banks referee themselves.
"Visa has operating regulations that govern how a transaction
flows," says Terrie Tweddle, a spokeswomanfor Visa Canada.
"The purpose behind these rules is to ensure that the card holder
has a similar experience regardless of where they are, anywhere
in the world."
Make refunds within 30 days
If you're in any way unhappy with an item purchased
with a credit card, your first step is returning to the merchant.
In doing this, bear in mind the store's refund policy. Most shops
have a 30-day refund policy, so if you show up with a temperamental
toaster on the 31st day, you should expect to be snubbed.
But if you return it within the 30-day period, you have a case.
If the store clerk refuses to do a refund, you should resort to
seven words of fail-safe intimidation: "I'd like to speak to
If the store still won't budge, your next avenue of recourse is
to tell the financial institution that issued your credit card.
(With a CIBC Aerogold Visa, for example, you would need to contact
CIBC rather than Visa.) In most cases, the two sides will settle
the dispute, and you should receive your refund.
The more troubling scenario is if you look at your credit-card
statement and find a transaction you're certain you didn't make.
In that case, you need to contact your credit-card issuer and ask
them to investigate potential fraud.
The bank will go back to the store and demand proof
of the purchase in question -- typically a sales slip with your
signature on it. In most cases, the matter will end there.
Zero-liability cards protect consumers from fraud
In rare cases, however, the store will present
a slip with an incriminating signature; it looks like yours, but
you're confident it didn't come from your hand. In this instance,
the customer must sign an affidavit refuting the validity of the
signature. The case then becomes a court proceeding, most likely
involving a handwriting expert.
"We tell people, reconcile your statements at the end of the
month to make sure there's nothing unauthorized," says Isabelle
Rodrigue, consumer education officer at the Financial Consumer Agency
of Canada in Ottawa. "If you do find something that you think
you didn't authorize, call your credit-card issuer right away."
The mere suggestion of fraud is enough to give consumers chills,
but most credit cards have a zero-liability policy in place. What
does that mean? In most cases, the credit-card issuer reimburses
the customer as soon as fraud is suspected.
If the transaction is later proved to be fraudulent, the card holder
has already been compensated; if the transaction is not fraudulent,
she is recharged for the amount on her credit card. Either way,
the customer does not pay interest for the duration of the investigation.
"We tell customers that they're more protected with a credit
card than they are with a debit card, just because they have this
zero-liability policy," says Rodrigue.
Awaiting your refund
A typical purchase will take between one and
two business days to hit your credit-card account. The amount of
time it takes to process the refund depends largely on how technologically
advanced the merchant is.
If you're dealing with a large department store like
Sears, it's connected to an electronic system. A refund at Sears
will be administered a lot more quickly than if you're dealing with
a small-town merchant who's jotting everything on old MasterCard
and Visa stubs and processing transactions manually or by phone.
One thing about using a credit card: You can't control
when a purchase -- or a subsequent refund -- hits your account.
It's very possible, for example, that you made a purchase in one
month, but were credited the refund the next month.
Many consumers assume that because they've returned the item, they
don't need to resolve their balance. It's quite possible, however,
that the credit-card company doesn't know that you've returned the
item, because the refund transaction hasn't registered in your account
In the world of credit, as soon as you make a purchase, you're
loaned money. So while it may seem a nuisance, you're still liable
for the whole amount of the credit-card statement.
If you pay off the disputed amount in the first month,
you should see a credit on your next statement. This, too, comes
with a stipulation: In most cases, credit cannot be redeemed for
cash. That means you'll have to work off your refund by using your
card for other purchases.
"The best thing to do is pay off the statement
in full even though you're paying off more money than you should,"
says Rodrigue. "The following month, when you get the credit,
use it up on essential purchases, like buying gas or groceries."
Andre Mayer is a freelance writer based in Toronto.