With most traditional
IRAs, these events would include:
reaching 59½, buying
a first home ($10,000 limit),
qualified college expenses,
qualified medical expenses
that exceed 7.5 percent of
gross income, paying medical
insurance premiums after a
job loss and disability. If
the account holder dies, a
beneficiary can take out money
without early distribution
penalties.
With a Roth
IRA, the account has to be
at least 5 years old, and
the events could include:
reaching 59½, purchase
of a first home (limit is
$10,000 in earnings), disability
and death. But with a Roth,
you can also take out your
contributions at any time
for any reason, without taxes
or penalties. It's the earnings
on those contributions that
are restricted.
When
it comes to IRAs, the Roth is king, says Bogosian. Roths are great for people
who want to save but don't know exactly what they are saving for. And since you
can make withdrawals, "Roths are a good parking spot for your emergency money,"
Bogosian says.
If you're working
past 70½, you don't
have to start taking money
out and you can keep contributing,
says Bogosian.
With a Roth
there is also some financial
security if you die or become
disabled because you or your
heirs can start taking disbursements
without any penalties, says
David Foster, CPA, CFP and
principal with Foster &
Motley Inc., in Cincinnati.
But once your
income starts to climb, Roths
are no longer an option. The
cutoff range is $95,000 to
$110,000 for individuals and
approximately $150,000 to
$160,000 for married couples,
says Bogosian.
There are also limits on
the amount you are allowed to contribute every year. If you're starting your contributions
later in life, it's more difficult to play catch-up. If you need to put away more
than the limit, "then the IRAs are off the table," says Natalie Choate,
author of "Life and Death Planning for Retirement Benefits."
With a traditional
IRA, you have to stop saving
and start taking money out
when you hit 70½ whether
you're working or not. And
if you want to take your money
out of a traditional IRA before
you retire, you could be subject
to taxes and penalties.
401(k)s
When it comes to investing for retirement, a company 401(k) plan
can give you the advantage of group buying. "Because of the buying power
inherent in these plans, you are able to get better rates; less expensive investments
than you or I could on our own," says Bogosian. "You get an institutional
price on investments."
If your employer offers a 401(k)
program and matches your contributions, you can leverage your savings.
Since
401(k) money is taken out before you see your paycheck, "it's
painless," says Picker. "You don't even have to write a check like you
do with the IRA."
You can also contribute more, which
makes it a great option for those who are starting late. If the individual plan
doesn't set limits, you could contribute up to $15,000 in 2006, or $20,000 if
you're 50 or older, says Picker.
The 401(k) gives
you more flexibility in setting your retirement age. You can stop working (and
start drawing on the account) as early as 55. Or you can keep working, continue
adding to the account and hold off retirement as long as you want. But you have
to keep working for the company that sponsors the plan.