Save for a rainy day? Most prefer to borrow

No savings on hand for rainy days You must have $5,000 immediately or die. Who do you turn to in your hour of need?

Don't expect mom, dad, brother, sister or your best friend to save you -- if you're like the Americans randomly surveyed by Gallup and Bankrate.com in the summer of 1998. Only 7 percent of the 1,000 respondents chose "family or friends" as a financial resource in an emergency.

When it comes to getting out of a tight financial spot, the respondents vastly prefer impersonal institutions to personal friends and family. Almost 70 percent were certain it would be "not at all difficult" to borrow $5,000 from a bank or by using credit cards.

"That would explain a phenomenon I've noticed recently," says Steve Rhode, co-founder of Myvesta.org, a Maryland based financial crisis counseling group. "Lately, when we advise middle-aged couples in a debt crisis, we're not surprised to find out we also have their parents as clients facing their own debt crisis."

Top five answers

"If some kind of emergency came up that cost about $5,000, where would you probably get this money?"

Borrow, including home equity loans, friends or family 45%
Withdraw from account or already have that much available 32%
Borrow, using credit cards 9%
Don't know where or how they could get the money 8%
Couldn't get their hands on this kind of money 4%
Source: Gallup/Bankrate.com survey

Giddy consumers
don't foresee rainy days

The survey numbers seem to paint a picture of consumers so giddy they scoff at rainy days. "They've forgotten what the world's like when it rains," Rhode says. "Consumers assume there will be money to borrow when the economy is booming. They don't realize that if there is a recession, very suddenly banks and credit card issuers have much less money to loan."

The Gallup survey demographics do not exactly mirror America: 85 percent white, 11 percent black, 2 percent Hispanic, 48 percent college graduates, 24 percent professional, 24 percent service and retail employees and 19 percent retired/disabled. But the research of psychologist Philip Levendusky reflects the attitude. He studies reckless behavior in general at McLean Hospital in Belmont, Mass.

Saving money is a precaution and, Levendusky discovered, Americans hate precautions. Whether it's wearing seat belts or condoms, he observed that only 30 percent of our nation will consistently perform a simple action to divert potential disaster. Another third will "do it sometimes, but not on a level that's therapeutic." The remaining third won't bother to do it at all.

Gen Xers taking saving to heart

- advertisement -
The one demographic cluster actually saving money is at the age more often stereotyped as walking on the wild side rather than putting aside an ounce of prevention. Consumers younger than 34 save at a rate far outpacing baby boomers, according to a 1998 study by financial consultant Frank Furash. These Gen Xers set aside income in 401(k) plans, Individual Retirement Accounts and certificates of deposit as well as traditional bank accounts. The young savers give Furash two major reasons for their frugality. First, twice as many young workers believe in the existence of UFOs as believe that Social Security will exist when they're ready to retire.

And they know that as the huge Boomer demographic finally blips its way into old age, a big chunk of Gen X paychecks will support Boomer retirements. When that rainy day hits young savers, they say their nest eggs will look like one shrewd precaution.

Related information:
More savings news
Search the latest savings rates
The basics: Savings
Definitions: Banking terms

-- Posted Nov. 20, 1998

 



top of page
 
- advertisement -