The best moves in mortgages
Most prime adjustables during
the 2004-06 period were 3/1 and 5/1 ARMs.
These loans had introductory rates that lasted
for three or five years; after that the rates
adjust (or reset) annually. Dates of that
first rate reset peaked in the summer of 2008,
but about half a million prime borrowers will
see their first reset in 2009.
 |
| Prime ARM resets by month, number of loans |
 |
|
|
2009 smart moves: Modify the mortgage
One of the big questions of 2009 -- politically, economically and financially -- will be: How do we mass-modify mortgages to avoid foreclosures? Coming up with an answer won't be easy.
A mortgage modification is an
alteration of the details of the existing
home loan. Usually, but not always, a modification
is done after the borrower has fallen behind
on the payments by 90 days or more. In a modification,
the borrower keeps the loan -- in other words,
it's not a refinance. Modifications are usually
done when the house is worth less than the
mortgage balance.
There are several ways to modify
a mortgage. Sometimes the term is extended
-- for example, a 30-year mortgage is turned
into a 40-year loan. In other cases the rate
is reduced. Or interest is charged on only
some of the loan balance. Occasionally, in
what's called a principal reduction, the lender
forgives some of the debt so that the borrower
no longer owes more than the house is worth.
Modifications traditionally
have been done one at a time, case by case.
But skyrocketing demand for mortgage modifications
will require companies to apply rules that
apply to large swaths of borrowers. The rules
will determine who gets a modification and
who doesn't. Controversy will result when
deserving people don't qualify for modifications,
while some undeserving people do.
When the government took over IndyMac, one of the country's largest mortgage servicers, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. set up rules designed to encourage mortgage modifications. Since then, the government has required lenders, such as Citigroup, to adopt the FDIC's mortgage modification rules as a condition for receiving federal aid.
It's too early to know how successful
the FDIC's mortgage modification plan will
be, but overall, modifications haven't worked
all that well. According to the Office of
the Comptroller of the Currency, more than
half of loans modified in the first three
months of 2008 had fallen behind on their
payments within six months.
FDIC Chairwoman Sheila Bair
questioned the comptroller data, saying that
it failed to distinguish "sustainable modifications
versus cosmetic modifications."
2009
smart moves: Home equity
Because of declining home values, lenders became reluctant in 2008 to underwrite new home equity loans and home equity lines of credit. That trend is likely to continue through 2009.
In areas where home prices are
falling fastest, lenders have been reducing
the limits on home equity lines of credit
or canceling them outright. The best advice
on home equity debt is the most basic: Keep
paying the monthly bills if you can.
|