Mortgages scarce on Native American
lands
By Holden Lewis Bankrate.com
It always has been difficult to get a mortgage in
Indian country. The federal government is remedying that situation,
with modest results.
Demand exists for mortgages on Native American lands,
usually referred to as Indian country. According to one study, 38,000
households on reservations and other Indian land have sufficient
income to qualify for conventional mortgages. But the number of
mortgages in Indian country is a fraction of that -- a consequence
of the special legal status of much Indian land.
As a result, many Native Americans on reservations
just have to make do. Many build their homes bit by bit, adding
onto the structure as they can afford to, says Gary Gordon, executive
director of the National American Indian Housing Council.
Other people resort to more desperate measures. Overcrowded
housing is rife in Native American communities. For a report that
the housing council issued in February 2002, researchers found as
many as 25 and 30 people living in three-bedroom houses. Some homes
lacked sufficient heat and plumbing.
With a desperate need for housing in Indian country,
and with thousands of families who could qualify for mortgages,
you would think that lenders would line up to underwrite home loans
on Indian lands. But they haven't, for two reasons.
First, much land on Indian reservations and tribal
areas is owned by the federal government and held in trust for the
tribe. A mortgage borrower on tribal trust land doesn't own the
parcel that the home sits on. The borrower has a long-term lease.
This limits the amount of money the lender can recover in case of
foreclosure because the lender can't sell the house and the land
it's on.
Another reason for the scarcity of mortgages in Indian
country is that many tribal lands fall under the jurisdiction of
tribal courts, which have their own laws and procedures governing
foreclosure and eviction. When an off-the-reservation lender wants
to foreclose on a delinquent mortgage borrower, it has to pursue
the matter through a civil tribal court. Some lenders have been
reluctant to trust tribal courts to carry out the eviction and foreclosure
process without favoring tribal members over the outside lenders.
The U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development has several programs
to increase homeownership on Indian reservations and other Native
American lands. The most important is called the Section 184 loan
guarantee. Under this program, if a borrower defaults and the lender
has to foreclose, the government pays the lender for any financial
loss.
Before a Section 184 loan goes through, it has to
be approved by HUD and the Bureau of Indian Affairs. The borrower
has to obtain a long-term lease from the tribe. That's on top of
the loan paperwork. With all the red tape, Gordon says the Section
184 program hasn't attracted many lenders, "and I think part
of it is the bureaucracy that's involved with that. It takes a long
time to approve and process these mortgages."
The Section 184 program has existed for 10 years.
As of March 31, some 916 of these loans were outstanding nationwide,
for a total of $89 million borrowed. With less than 1,000 mortgages
in 10 years, it would take quite some time to satisfy that demand
for 38,000 mortgages. To be fair, it took years for the Section
184 program to gain traction, and most of those loans have been
originated since 1999.
A mortgage through the Section 184 program isn't necessarily
an ideal loan. Native Americans have long complained that high-interest,
subprime
mortgages are too common in Indian country.
"More tribes are trying to establish and develop
financial literacy courses for tribal members so they can become
more aware of predatory lending," Gordon says.
|