Bankrate.com Archives
 

Dorothy Rosen -- The Dollar Diva Money Makeover

Money Makeover: Mall mania becomes debt nightmare

Jo Ann Hudson loves to shop. She works eight hours, sleeps eight hours and spends most of the rest of her time at the mall. "I mostly shop for anything that will enhance my appearance: clothes, shoes, makeup, jewelry, purses, hair appointments." The last thing Jo Ann needs is appearance enhancement: She's young, thin, healthy and beautiful.

- advertisement -

Jo Ann has racked up a whopping $22,480 in unsecured debt and owes another $13,570 for her gas-guzzling SUV. Debt has become a way of life for her. She borrowed more than $6,000 from her parents to pay off student loans and other debts and recently hit rock bottom when she borrowed $800 from a co-worker to pay an American Express bill.

Jo Ann is bending under the pressure of the debt and has reached out to the Diva for help: "I make $40,000 a year and haven't been able to save a dime. If something were to happen to my car, if I lost my job or had a sudden major medical expense, I don't know what I would do. Help! I am only 25 and cannot figure out how to get my finances under control."

The Diva responds to Jo Ann's cry for help.

Expense chart

Tracking expenses and understanding the underlying problem
Jo Ann's net pay is $2,200 a month. Almost half of it goes to paying off debt; she spends $640 to service her unsecured debt and $360 for her car loan. This debt load has her spending $490 more each month than she brings in.

As soon as Jo Ann saw how serious the deficit spending was she decided to cut expenses to the barest of bare bones. Jo Ann's credit rating is good, and she wants to keep it that way.

Here are the cuts that will get her out of the red:
Clothes ($200): Jo Ann has more clothes, shoes and accessories than she needs.
Gifts ($60): She will use her arts and crafts skills to make personal gifts for friends and family.
Beauty salon ($50): Skip the beauty parlor until the debts are paid off.
Dining out ($30): Brown bag lunches until the debts are paid off.
Movies ($20): Library and other free activities will replace movies.
Vacations ($130): The trip to Peru earlier this year added $1,400 to the debt. No more fancy vacations until the debts are paid off.

Jo Ann says, "I want to get my finances under control and understand why I need to spend more than I have." The Money Makeover will help Jo Ann get her finances under control but helping her understand the negative behavior pattern is outside the Diva's area of practice. Luckily, the momentum for change is there, and Jo Ann is finding help in all the right places.

Jo Ann's mother and boyfriend suspected that her overspending might be compulsive behavior and urged her to attend a Debtors Anonymous meeting. This happened during the course of the Makeover. "I've gone to a couple of meetings and so far I really like it," she tells the Diva. "I'll let you know more after I've been going for awhile." Debtors Anonymous is a 12-step program fashioned after Alcoholics Anonymous. It encourages and supports abstinence from unsecured debt -- one day at a time.

Debt repayment chart

The Diva's "payment push" strategy
Jo Ann's belt-tightening puts her in a break-even position, but it doesn't free up extra cash for debt payments. Once again, her parents are offering a helping hand. She pays them $200 a month on their $6,020 interest-free loan; they're going to let her defer payments on this loan until her high-interest credit card debts are paid off.

If she continues to make minimum payments on her $15,660 credit card debt, Jo Ann will still be making payments 30 years from now and she will lay out $27,000 in interest payments. The extra $200 each month coupled with the Diva's "payment push" strategy will have the credit card debt paid off in three years and five months.

Here's how the "payment push" strategy will work for Jo Ann:

  • She will make a schedule of the debts including: (1) debt name, (2) balance due, (3) interest rate, (4) time period for the "payment push" and (5) how to fund the "payment push."
  • She will place her co-worker's $800 no-interest loan on top of the list. This type of loan is odious to both the lender and the borrower and must be eradicated swiftly. The extra $200 from deferring the payments to her parents will clean this up in three months.
  • The remaining debt gets ranked by interest rate, putting the 23 percent Citibank debt on the top and the parents' no-interest loan on the bottom. She should express her gratitude to her parents for this generous gesture at least once a month.
  • The same monthly payments are made on all of the other debts.
  • As soon as the co-worker's loan is paid off, the $100 freed up from the original loan payment plus the $200 freed up from the parents' loan is used to pay down the debt with the highest interest rate (Citibank).
  • Once the debt with the highest interest rate is paid off, the cash that is freed up is used to pay down the debt with the next highest interest rate. And so it goes until all the balances read zero.
  • Raises, bonuses, tax refunds and all cash windfalls get added to the "payment push" pot so the debts are paid off ASAP.

By following the Diva's "payment push" strategy, all of Jo Ann's debt, including her car loan, will be paid off before she's 30, giving her an extra $1,000 in cash to manage each month.

Managing her excess cash
Jo Ann needs to plan for that happy day when she's debt free. Here are some suggestions for managing the extra $1,000 in disposable income she's going to have each month:

  • Make life more fun ($200)
  • Build an emergency fund ($600)
  • Add to her 401(k) plan ($100)
  • Save up for things on her "wish list," such as a leather jacket and laser surgery ($100)

Saving $600 a month will create a $7,200 emergency fund in a year. After that, the $600 can be used to make maximum contributions to Jo Ann's 401(k) plan and allow her to save for long-term goals like an exotic vacation, the down payment on a home and accumulating enough wealth to be financially independent.

Conclusion
Jo Ann is determined to turn her fortunes around. She has looked her debt in the eye, knows how it got there and what she has to do to get rid of it. Jo Ann is a very smart, motivated 25-year-old woman; she has embraced the concept of abstinence from debt, one day at a time, and the Diva thinks she's going to succeed.

-- Posted: Aug. 10, 2001

 

Vital Signs
  Name
  Marital status
  Age
  Occupation
  Take-home pay
  Hobbies
  Car
  Savings
  Investments
  Retirement savings
  Home equity
  Car loan
 
Unsecured debt
 

-- Posted: Aug. 10, 2001

30 yr fixed mtg 3.89%
48 month new car loan 3.62%
1 yr CD 0.65%
Alerts
Ask the experts
Related features
Win $100! Share your cost-cutting tip.
Advice columnists
Ask Dr. Don
Tax Talk
Debt Adviser
Real Estate Adviser
Quizzes
Are you ready for a mortgage?
How scamproof are you?
Archives
Advice channel archive
News archive
   
 
   
 
   
 
   
 
   
 
   
Checkup

Buy our book
Your Financial Action Plan
Learn more
- advertisement -
 
- advertisement -