Insuring your teen driver without breaking the bank
teenagers count the days until they can get behind the wheel of the family car
and cruise. Many of their parents count the days, too, but for entirely different
For the teens, it means freedom and fun. For
their parents, it means sleepless nights and lighter wallets.
The parents' concerns are valid. Drivers under
25 are four times as likely as older drivers to die in an accident, reports
the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
As a result, adding a 16-year-old driver to
your auto insurance policy can come with a hefty price tag. Premium increases
of 50 to 100 percent are not unheard of, says Loretta Worters, spokeswoman with
the New York-based trade group Insurance Information Institute.
Fortunately, you can take steps to rein in
Comparison shop for teen-driver prices, says Lewis Mandell, professor of finance
at the University of Buffalo in Buffalo, N.Y. While rates for 40-somethings
may be fairly standard among insurers, that's not always the case.
Consider a higher deductible. Going from a $250 to $500 or $1,000
deductible can save you 10 percent to 20 percent on your premium, says Madelyn
Flannagan, vice president of education and research for the Independent
Insurance Agents and Brokers of America, an Alexandria, Va.-based
professional association. You'll want to weigh
whether you can absorb the out-of-pocket expense in the event of an accident.
You'll also want to evaluate taking out a separate policy for
Assuming you and your spouse have a good claims record, you're
probably best off simply adding your teen driver to your own policy and paying
the increased premium, says Robert Klein, director of the Center for Risk Management
and Insurance Research at Georgia State University in Atlanta.
On the other hand, if your driving record leaves a lot to be desired
or you drive expensive cars, it may be less expensive to get your teen a separate
Down the road, you'll want to check just when your insurer classifies
young drivers as adults. At that point, you should see a decrease in your rates,
says Gwen Reichbach, director of the National Institute for Consumer Education
at Eastern Michigan University.
While many companies classify drivers as adults at age 25, some
offer lower rates for 23-year-old drivers. Drivers who marry, even if they're
younger than 25, may qualify for lower auto premiums. Also, as your teen becomes
a twenty-something, it's worth checking whether he or she should move to a separate
If you're planning to purchase another car, think carefully
about your choices. While your son or daughter may be begging for a new sports
car, a safe and stodgy used car will be easier on your insurance rates. It's
less likely to be stolen, and probably will do better in a crash test. Your
premiums should reflect these differences.
Should you get a car, it probably will make sense to keep
it in your name, says Mandell.
"Typically, parents have more assets, so they take greater
responsibility," he says. Thus, insurers are likely to charge a lower premium.
Whether or not you buy another car, you can ask your insurer to
assign your teen driver to just one of your cars. In other words, the insurer
would calculate your premium under the assumption that your teenager only drives
a specific car, typically a less expensive one.
Be warned, however: Many insurers will not assign certain cars
to certain drivers; they assume anyone in the house can drive any of the cars.
And, according to the Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of America, you
can expect that the insurance company will also price the premium based on the
highest risk vehicle on your policy.
If your insurance carrier agrees to assign your teen to a specific
car, you need to lay down the law. Your new driver should take only the car
to which he or she is assigned, even in an emergency.
If your teen drives another car and gets in an accident, your
rates likely will get a hefty boost. Your insurer could even impose a penalty
or decide not to renew your policy.
Making the grade
Let your insurance company know if your child has a B or
better grade average. Studies have shown a correlation between good students
and responsible drivers, so many insurers offer good-student discounts, which
typically range from 5 percent to 10 percent, says Flannagan.
It also helps to have your child take a driver's education
course, rather than try to teach him or her the rules of the road yourself.
(In some states, teens must take a driver's education course to get a license
at age 16; otherwise, they have to wait until they're 18.)
Such courses can be good for discounts of up to 15 percent, says
Worters. Just make sure the course you have in mind is approved by your insurer.
In addition, some insurers offer "safe driver programs."
Teen participants in these programs sign contracts stating that they won't,
for instance, drink and drive. Check with your insurance company. If your teenager
completes the program, you may be able to cut another 5 percent or so from your
More states have now enacted what are known as "graduated
licenses." New drivers are restricted from certain activities, such as
driving with passengers, until they've had their licenses for a set period,
such as six months.
If you live in one of these states, ask if any discounts are available.
Some insurers may take a few percentage points off your increase.
Finally, you may be eligible for lower premiums once your teen
heads to college. Many insurers will reduce rates for students attending a school
at least 100 miles away from home and who don't have a car on campus, says Worters
of the Insurance Information Institute.
What not to do
As you're checking out insurance for your teen driver, you'll
want to avoid these mistakes.
First, don't procrastinate. As soon as your teenager is ready
to get a permit, let your insurance company know. If you forget and your child
is involved in an accident, your insurance company generally will cover it,
says Worters. However, it can retroactively charge the higher premium that you
should have been paying. In an extreme case, it could revoke your coverage.
You also don't want to drastically lower your liability coverage
in order to reduce your rate increase, says Klein. Granted, doing so may save
a few dollars now. However, it doesn't make sense to carry less coverage on
a higher-risk driver. Should your teenager get into an accident, you'll be forced
to cover the damages from your own pocket.
Ultimately, helping your son or daughter establish a good
driving record will be your best protection against sky-high insurance rates.
Of course, the primary objective of driving safely is to prevent injuries and
However, traffic violations and accidents also directly affect
your pocketbook. If your teenager's drinking or recklessness results in an accident,
your premiums can jump by several hundred percent.
The longer your teenager motors along without an accident
or traffic violation, the more you'll be able to negotiate lower premiums. More
importantly, you'll know that your son or daughter is less likely to be involved
in an accident.
Karen Kroll is a freelance writer
based in Minnesota.
Pat Curry contributed to this story.
-- Posted: Sept. 23, 2003