Helping in-laws out of credit card debt
| Dear
Debt Adviser, My in-laws, who are both over 65, are living on Social
Security. They have no savings, about $35,000 equity in a house valued at $70,000
and approximately $30,000 in credit card debt. I realize I must address their
spending habits to prevent future debt and am working on a spending plan for them
now. What and how is the best way to eliminate their credit card debt? Should
they refinance? Should they take a home equity loan? Should I buy their house
and let them pay me rent, not to exceed their current mortgage payment? Thanks
in advance for your answer. -- Harry
Dear Harry, I think your in-laws are lucky to have you. I'm more than
a little concerned that you are the one writing to me, not the in-laws or their
offspring. You are right on track with working out a spending plan. However, it
is critical that the in-laws participate in this process. It will be much easier
for them to stick to the plan if they feel it's their plan, not yours.
You said they are over 65. I assume you picked that
number because they are not over any other round number such as
70 or 80. Heck, for that matter, at 85 my father was a ball of fire! So
most likely, they are far from feeble and helpless. In fact, they
probably are still employable, at least part time. Some great community
service organizations can help them re-enter the work force with
confidence and dignity. Check with your local United Way or chamber
of commerce for some recommendations.
Be wary of taking over their finances. Not having savings
is a real problem, whether you are 65 or 35. If there is no really
good reason for this lack of a nest egg, be doubly careful how much
you offer to help. You are not a retirement plan!
Here's my advice. Try it, then stand
aside and see what happens.
First, have a long talk to help them see clearly why
they have this much debt on credit cards this late in the game.
They have to understand what they did so they can stop doing it
in the future.
Next, have them put together a spending plan and include
debt payments. Encourage them to include some part-time or even
full-time work. Work stimulates, helps pay the bills and it's harder
to spend money while working than when idle.
They have so few assets that I'd be wary of tapping
the house for funds via a home equity loan unless it is part of an overall plan
to improve their financial situation. Your offer to buy the home and then charge
them rent may sound like a dream come true to them. But think of the potential
for the deal to become a nightmare for you if they can't or won't make the payments.
You'll have absolutely no practical recourse in that situation.
If they want to look into a reverse mortgage, I'd suggest
you send them to a good HUD-approved HECM, or home equity conversion
mortgage, credit counselor to see if that makes any sense. They
won't be alone! David Jones, president of the Association
of Independent Consumer Credit Counseling Agencies, says he's noticed
a "major uptick" in older clients seeking counseling.
Paying
the minimum
amounts due on credit card balances can be frustrating and takes
around seven to 10 years to accomplish payoff, depending on the
lenders' policies. Getting relief in the form of lower interest
payments may make a real difference. Many lenders have hardship
programs that seniors (and others) may request and for which they
may qualify. These programs lower the interest rate on the balance
due, which allows more of the payments to pay off principal.
If their reduced spending plan does not free up enough
money to make some sort of significant payment on the debt, then
bankruptcy may be a reasonable alternative to consider. Lastly,
be careful of community
property laws if your state has them and be sure to use a good
attorney who is sensitive to elder issues if you go down that road.
Your in-laws have years of life ahead, and it is not too late for
them to plan for them. Offer them advice, love, compassion and encouragement
-- but resist the urge to be their savior.
Good luck!
The Debt Adviser, Steve Bucci, is the president
of Money Management International Financial Education Foundation
and the author of "Credit
Repair Kit for Dummies." Visit MMI
for additional debt advice or to ask a question of the Debt Adviser
go to the "Ask the
Experts" page and select "debt" as the topic.
|