- advertisement -
Columns: Driving for Dollars
Terry Jackson   Expert: Terry Jackson
Driving for Dollars
Car owner finds $8,248 discrepancy in loan payments
Driving for Dollars

Oops ... did my lender mess up?
 

Dear Terry,
Last year I took out an auto loan of $32,900.49 with APR of 4.99 percent for 60 months. My credit union calculated my monthly payment (also written on the contract) to be $465.11 and gave me 60 payment coupons to be accompanied with the check each month. But I just realized that this monthly payment amount is substantially smaller than what I should have been paying -- $620.72 per month, according to Bankrate's auto loan calculator. Does this mean that my legal obligation is to only pay the amount based on the coupons or $32,900.49 + 4.99 percent?
-- Alan

- advertisement -

Dear Alan,
Even financial institutions make mistakes, though this one seems to be a whopper, since your total payments of $465.11 for 60 months will equal only $27,906.60, far short of the $37,243.20 for a loan of $32,900.49 for 60 months at 4.99 percent. The calculated payment amount of $465.11 would have been for a loan of $24,652.49 over the same 60 months at the same 4.99 percent. Considering that the 49 cents appears in both loan amounts, it strikes me as perhaps more than a coincidence. Are you sure you didn't trade in a car on this deal and get the difference of $8,248 knocked off?

Assuming it wasn't a trade or a combination of trade and rebates, I'd say you have two choices: Point out the error to the credit union and see what you can work out, or consult a lawyer about whether you can be held liable for the shortfall once the loan is paid off.

I'd recommend consulting a lawyer first so you know where you stand before contacting the credit union.

This week
'New' Chrysler may mean more competitive pricing
Does saving gas really save me money?
How can I rescue my fugitive car?
Did my lender make an $8,200 mistake?
Bankrate.com's corrections policy -- Posted: May 26, 2007
Read more Driving for Dollars columns
Ask a question

Auto Loans
Compare today's rates
NATIONAL OVERNIGHT AVERAGES
48 month new car loan 7.30%
60 month new car loan 7.40%
48 month used car loan 7.89%
ADVERTISING PARTNERS
RELATED CALCULATORS
  Auto loan calculator  
  A rebate or special dealer financing?  
  How much will the auto lease really cost?  
VIEW ALL  
FINANCIAL LITERACY
Rev up your portfolio
with these tips and tricks.
Charles Schwab
- advertisement -
- advertisement -