|
Hedge funds can be
rewarding for the brave
By Stephen
Rothman Bankrate.com
Some of the nation's largest banks
have begun offering their wealthiest customers a chance to become
even richer by taking a chance on hedge funds.
"This
is where the action is,'' said George Van, chairman of Van
Hedge Fund Advisers International, which monitors 2,700 funds
here and abroad.
Hedge
funds are about managing risk. By betting a stock will go up in
value, and simultaneously betting that it will drop, hedge fund
managers try to ensure that investors don't loose it all, explained
David Harvey, founder of the Everest Partners L.P. hedge fund in
Nashville, Tenn. That's what hedging is all about.
As
with other investments sold by banks, cash in hedge funds is not
guaranteed against loss by the FDIC or other government agencies.
Susan
Weeks, a spokeswoman for $281 billion-asset Citicorp
based in New York, said the bank only offers hedge funds to institutional
investors or private bank investors who have $3 million or more
in net worth available.
Only
for the "very wealthy"
"We
are talking about the very wealthy. The sophisticated investor,"
she said, adding the hedge fund opportunity is "risk tailored to
the customer himself."
A
spokeswoman for $320 billion-asset Bankers Trust New York Corp.,
which doesn't offer retail banking, takes the same position. Last
year, Bankers Trust received the Micropal Off-Shore Fund Data Base
of London's award for having the best performing fund in 1996.
Indeed,
"These (funds) are not for the fainthearted because there is high
risk in this class of investment,'' said Dennis Grabow, head of
the Millennium Investment Corp., a Chicago-based hedge fund.
Harvey,
considered a gray beard in an industry that took off only in 1993,
believes hedge funds fail for two reasons. They accept more money
than they can adequately manage or fail to screen investors for
patience or intelligence.
"You
don't want investors who are going to want their money back at the
most inappropriate moment," said Harvey.
SEC
doesn't say where to invest
The
Security and Exchange
Commission does not interfere in how or where a hedge fund invests.
Grabow
has established a hedge fund based on his belief that at least 400
of the nation's banks will fail due to computer glitches that occur
at the start of the year 2000. Most computers are programmed to
read only the last two digits of the year and currently are unable
to distinguish between 1900 and 2000.
The
SEC, however, does have rules on who can participate as an investor.
An
individual must have earned $250,000 during the last two years before
applying for hedge fund membership or have a net worth of $1 million.
A couple must have earned $300,000 or have a $1 million net worth,
Van said.
That
means a lot of people qualify. "Anyone who bought property in California
15 years ago would meet the net worth standard. Anyone living in
New York City, including the garbage man, probably could meet the
income test," Harvey said, but that doesn't mean they are "smart
enough" to pick or handle hedge fund risks.
Reward
matches the risk
Traditionally,
hedge funds have been "the preserve of wealthy people who had money
they could risk. The reward is great when they hit, but so is the
risk" when they don't, said James Abbott, a partner in the 144-year-old
law firm of Carter, Ledyard & Milburn which specializes in setting
up domestic, foreign and offshore hedge funds.
In
1997, a year when the Standard and Poor's stock index showed a 33.4
percent profit, the best-performing hedge fund returned 46.9 percent,
Van Hedge Funds reported. However the average hedge fund made only
20.9 percent.
In
the old days, the SEC limited a hedge fund to no more than 99 persons
who could invest up to $5 million. Recently, the SEC changed the
rules to allow a pool of up to 500 investors who could put a total
of $15 million into the fund.
"This
has allowed a number of investment firms to flog (a hedge fund proposal)
through a brokerage firm, as long as they make sure they don't sell
it to mom and pop" who might lose their life savings, Abbott said.
Whether
it's an individual, pension fund or insurance company, the question
remains the same: "How much are you willing to risk for a greater
return," said Abbott.
The
hedge fund manager wants to win big, he said, because he gets 20
percent of the profits made off investors' money.
Manager
gets 1 percent to pay expenses of fund
"The
incentive for him is to make risky investments, but not so risky
that he blows it," Abbott said, adding the manager also gets 1 percent
of the money invested to pay for the fund's expenses.
So
now that the risks are known, how is a hedge fund selected? For
Duane Moyers, vice president of Investors Strategic Partners 1 Ltd.
of Fort Worth, Texas, there are two key elements.
"You
need to investigate the manager's style of investing and how much
risk he is willing to take (with your money)," Moyers said, adding
that he recommends that no individual put more than 20 percent of
their net worth into a hedge fund.
"There
have been some high profile disasters in the hedge fund arena over
the last four or five years," Moyers said.
One
occurred in 1995 when Morgan Stanley & Co.'s Global Opportunity
Fund collapsed, wiping out the $120 million offshore investment
by its 14 corporate and private investors.
One
high profile disaster
They
investors filed suit March 11 in New York Supreme Court charging
Morgan Stanley International
with fraud and misrepresentation. Investors allege they were induced
to invest in what they were told was a low-risk investment with
a goal of preservation of capital. They say it turned out to be
quite something else.
In
some cases, a hedge fund runs into trouble when managers use too
much leverage in trying to maximize the return. For instance, if
the fund takes in $100 million, the fund manager may go out and
borrow $1 billion -- 10 times what he has in assets.
"If
there is a dangerous downturn, the $100 million can get blown out
of the market along with the investors," Moyers said, adding all
it takes is one bad year to shut a fund down.
Today,
Moyers said, "it's hard to find a hedge fund manager that has been
around three years or longer," because a lot have guessed wrong
on the market.
"Today
the market is up. But when it heads down again, they will be writing
more disaster stories about hedge funds," Moyers said, adding "there
are a lot of mine fields out there to catch them."
-- Posted: March 26, 1998
|